Although I haven't seen the other pools (only SAB in January) we were very happy with the Polynesian. It was great for our 2 yr old DS. They have a zero-entry pool, so we did not have to carry him all the time. He could walk in and even sit down on his own. They also have waterfalls we would stick his head in. And there are also pop-jets (off to the side of the pool) which were great. I could just sit on a lounge chair while he played in the sprinklers for about 20mins before we went in everyday. And we did use the pool everyday we were there. There is also a nice tunnel-slide for older kids. Happy planning & Have a great vacation!