We really enjoyed Cape May. WC, not so much: found it louder than most TS restaurants (although most of them are pretty loud) and didn't think the food quality was all that.
We've been to CM many times and have never been disappointed. I always have to waddle back to our room afterwards. We have only been to WC once...........meh and loud.
I really enjoyed CM. My dad loved the crab legs and clams yum! I can't say much for WC for we've never been. My kids are extremely shy so we would never go to WC or 50s.
the best clam chowder, crab legs, desserts. Went to WC a couple times, got the skillet and was so disappointed - everything in one greasy pan Don't even remember if they had seafood, but would never go there for that - it's Cape May all the way for us - at least twice each trip