I don't really have any. Of course, I'm not quite as experienced as others on this board

. (For all my knowledge about how Dining Reservations work and the math being the Dining Plans... I've only been once in the past 18 years (previous trips were a bunch until 1992 (when I was a kid), then 2009).
However...
Depending on when you're going, keep an eye out for the Via Napoli and Hacienda de San Angel reservations too. They're both slated to open some time this fall and if they coincide with your trip, they may be nice choices. Just a different thought

.
I can remember begging my parents to go to Tutto (well, it wasn't Tutto yet, but I simply don't remember the name... this was 1992 I believe) because I liked spaghetti. We went, and out of all the fancy stuff, I had spaghetti and meatballs

. I think I did the same thing on an earlier trip regarding San Angel too, except I had tacos or something plain. Looking back, I really wonder what I missed out on. (I guess that's why my next trip is mostly about the dining huh).
I don't believe that the
DDP can be added to a one night stay and if you could you would have to buy a ticket as part of the package, so clearly OOP is your only option.
DH loved the meal he had at Tutto last Sept. (I was under the weather and didn't eat much.)


You can add the DDP to any length resort stay (up to 14 days, as that's the max for a single package), but yes, you would have to buy another ticket through Disney in order to add it so it may not be a good idea at this point.