I voted for the Polynesian, even though it's not my favorite WDW resorts.
Out of the choices you give, I think the Poly would best be suited for a honeymoon. The views of the castle from the Poly beach is a nice way to end your evening. The convenience of the monorail to the Magic Kingdom and Epcot and the tropical ambiance of the Poly seem to say "honeymoon" more than the WL or the AKL, in my opinion.