I would say for your family either Movies or Sports. If your boys like Toy Story then Movies would be great! Sports is what my son picked for his birthday trip this October (he will be 11 so he is getting beyond the Toy Story thing I guess!). We stayed at Movies last October and our kids were 8 and 10 and they both loved it. Really cute theming. I see a lot of posts about bus sharing between All Stars and I know they do that but when we were there we only shared a bus once. That was coming back from MK one morning only about two hours after the park opened so nobody was going back then so it made total sense for them to run just one bus. Even with the sharing that day there was only about 8 people on the bus and 4 of them were us! I think if it is a busy time you won't necessarily have to share a bus, that was certainly our experience. One nice thing is that the All Stars are all right together so it is a piece of cake to check all three of them out and take lots of cute pictures with the icons. You can also pool hop between the three All Stars since they are sister resorts. We loved our stay at Movies last October and in fact are probably the only family alive that preferred Movies over Pop Century! Loved Pop too but missed all the dalmations and Toy Story icons!