Where to eat anniversary dinner?

[wmears95]

We are celebrating our anniversary in WDW at the end of May. We have the DDP and would like a romantic anniversary dinner. We are staying at POFQ and are willing to use 2 TS credits. We will have a rental car, so transportation is not the issue. No kids, no time crunch either.
I feel like we have such a wide range of options! We could eat in the parks or the resorts. I am a "foodie", but dh, not so much. We live on a farm and he typically will order steak everwhere we go! (Usually, it is not as good as what we have at home because we raise our own beef.) He does enjoy seafood and pasta also.
I am leaning towards AP at the WL. We have visited there and it felt very "homey". I am having our travel agent help with ADRs but need to get on the ball...our trip got moved up by about 5 months!
Any suggestions?

(He is leaving all the planning up to me and I am starting to feel the stress! )

 

[OandA]

Yachtsman. Very nice restaurant.

 

[disneydeb1224]

We have spent our anniversary at the California Grill several times, and loved it
!!! Try to book near the time of the Wishes fireworks!!! Happy Anniversary!!!

 

[Pakey]

AP is a very nice choice. It's quieter than many of the signatures and does have that rustic homey feel to it. Service is always good here.

I would skip Ca Grill, Flying Fish, Brown Derby and Narcoosees because they are generally noisier. That leaves Jiko, Citricos, Yachtsman and AP. Jiko and Citricos have more complex entrees which your husband may not like and Yachtsman definitely does not have the best steaks (although atmosphere is nice).