When it's time to end a friendship

VandVsmama

DIS Veteran
Joined
Mar 28, 2011
Messages
8,925
Another poster's experience on this thread got me thinking. Sometimes, you know that it's time to end a friendship when you encounter something so incredibly uncaring and horrible that you can't imagine spending any more time with the person. And other times, the friendship is a slow death over time...made worse in a way by social media and one's reluctance to official un-friend someone on Facebook & other apps.

In my case, my friendship with a roommate from college withered away and then she did a couple of pretty insulting things that resulted in my mental light switch in my head switch to "Off" mode. For example:

Friend & I met freshman year in college. She was new to our dorm & moved in part way into the school year. I helped her move into her room & invited her to join a group of girls that I was friends with because I didn't want her to feel out of place and alone. We totally hit it off. She went to my wedding, and I was a bridesmaid in her wedding. We lived in other parts of the country for several years, then circumstances were such that we both ended up living in the same city when DH & I were about to have children.

She was a lifesaver...we'd compare notes on our kids, we would go out together once a month for a moms' night out (that saved my sanity when my kids were infants), we helped each other out and supported each other. We'd take our kids trick-or-treating together at Halloween every year. And one year, we celebrated Thanksgiving together. It was a lot of fun.

Fast forward a few years to when ODD was entering kindergarten. Looking back, the signs of trouble were there back then. Friend started bragging about how much better her kids' elementary school was than ours, lectured me about how I should use open enrollment to enroll ODD in her elementary school, etc., etc. DH & I chose differently.

2 of her kids were really into dance & she'd brag about how great the dance studio was. We tried it out with ODD & YDD when they were little for about a year. Then it became obvious that to do it more often was too cost prohibitive and we stopped going. She took it as a personal insult.

About a year and a half after that, the moms' nights out started to happen very sporadically. And when she & I would be out to dinner, she would be calling another friend of hers to make plans to meet Other Friend for drinks after Other Friend got off work (Other Friend worked at a restaurant at the time). No invitation came from her to me to join them. Yet there she is making other plans with someone else right in front of me...and bragging about how great this other person is, how much cooler she is than me, etc.

Around this same time, Friend's eldest daughter enters the teenage years. Her ODD is very girly and is a lovely young lady inside and out. Friend would repeatedly make snarky comments to me IN FRONT of her ODD about the ODD's beauty routine, about ODD's popularity at school (she had a lot of friends, unlike Friend, who has always been very introverted). It was uncomfortable to listen to. What kind of mom would be jealous of her own child? I just didn't understand that.

She was a Girl Scout leader for her kids' girl scout troops. But she hated it. At least, I thought she did because she complained about it nonstop. yet she wanted, insisted that I enroll my kids in Girl Scouts, too. We thought about it and decided not to for a couple of reasons. Friend was upset & insulted. If I had enrolled the kids in Girl Scouts, they wouldn't have been in Friend's troop anyway.

Then when my ODD was in 1st grade, we made the decision to enroll her for 2nd grade in a charter school. YDD would be entering kindergarten that year as well. Friend was horrified and personally insulted...again. She wouldn't let it go, told me repeatedly mean things like, "Oh you're going to hate it there. Just you wait. I give it two years and then you'll be back at XYZ Public School and you'll be wishing that you listened to me. You'll see. Good luck with that."

Then she stopped returning my calls. I stopped calling her as often as I used to. That same year on Christmas Eve, I called her house to wish her and her family a merry Christmas. She never returned my call. That was the last straw. Just the year before, we'd had Thanksgiving together and 12 months later, she's not even speaking to me.

Looking back, I think that perhaps she saw the latter years of our friendship in a different way...perhaps she saw herself as superior and more knowledgeable than I and that I relied on her for parenting & child rearing advice and perhaps she got a lot out of that. I, on the other hand, saw us as equals.

A couple of months after the "no return phone call Christmas," I ran into her in the grocery store. I was very happy to see her. We ran into each other in the dairy section. I said to her, "Oh hi, So-and-So! It's so great to see you! What are you doing here this evening?" She looked like she wanted to run away and didn't say a word, so I filled in the conversation with, "Oh, haha! How stupid of me! Of course you're here doing the same thing that I am...grocery shopping! Well, I won't keep you! It was great to see you!" The latter part of that I said to her as she turned her cart the opposite direction and started walking away from me without saying a word.

A woman who I'd been close friends with for about 20 years. Treated me like a total stranger at the grocery store. That was it. I unfriended her from Facebook later that day, removed her contact info from my phone & email, and that was that.

It's now been about 2 years since that happened. My kids are still at the Evil Charter School she said we'd hate...and they're doing just fine. I'm still FB friends with her DH.
 
I think that all you wrote, tells me that you have already answered your own question. Sounds like she couldn't even be civil and courteous the last time you ran into her. :(
 
I have let some friendships go, not 20 year long, but 5-10. Friends who are too negative are the ones I try to distance myself from. Everyone has enough drama in their own life to not have friends add to it!

At our previous school, there was more drama among the moms than the girls. So glad to have left all of that behind.
 

I have let go of friendships as some of them were very unhealthy. I need healthy ones not ones that would lead me in negative directions.
 
About a year and a half after that, the moms' nights out started to happen very sporadically. And when she & I would be out to dinner, she would be calling another friend of hers to make plans to meet Other Friend for drinks after Other Friend got off work (Other Friend worked at a restaurant at the time). No invitation came from her to me to join them. Yet there she is making other plans with someone else right in front of me...and bragging about how great this other person is, how much cooler she is than me, etc.

An adult told you someone else is "cooler than you"? Yeah. Um, that would be the last time I would be in the presence of someone that immature and strange. That's when the friendship would have totally ended for me.
 
Maybe her perspective of this story would sound different? The way you described it makes it seem as if she decided to end the friendship before you did. It's good that you've moved on and are not still pining for her. Lots of relationships are for a season only, not forever.
 
These are always hard questions for me, in general I think folks use the word "friends" a lot differently than me. Yesterday I had breakfast with my friend John, we were next door neighbors since I was 5, that's over 50 years so it would take a lot for me to drop him. that being said if one of my friends started acting out of character, I would start investigating immediately. in your case op, I would have been searching for answers as to why she suddenly became so insulting and belittling

Interestingly enough my 4 best friends (2 college, 2 childhood) and I don't do facebook. lol. We talk almost every other day.

If one of my good friends stop taking my calls, I'd be on her door step banging, but as I said 40 years is a long time, those are blessings I wouldn't readily give up
 
I'm guessing she'd view things differently than you. You have a very negative description of her based on nothing more than your take on conversations with her. Maybe she thinks you were the one who thought you were superior to her. I don't know, it all sounds childish.
 
About a year and a half after that, the moms' nights out started to happen very sporadically. And when she & I would be out to dinner, she would be calling another friend of hers to make plans to meet Other Friend for drinks after Other Friend got off work (Other Friend worked at a restaurant at the time). No invitation came from her to me to join them. Yet there she is making other plans with someone else right in front of me...and bragging about how great this other person is, how much cooler she is than me, etc.

I would have walked away at that point.
 
Many of those things would have me walking away but when I go out with someone and they get on their phone and start phoning other people, that's when I exit. If I'm that boring (and maybe I am) then maybe she could go with those better friends instead of me right off the bat.
 
When they no longer treat me with respect, I start to re-evaluate. If I feel I am the one to always give and don't get anything back I start to re-evaluate. I am not saying I end the friendship but I think about things. If I feel as though I no longer am getting anything out of the friendship, I will let it slide awhile. I have also reconnected after some years and had a stronger bond.
 
Based on what you have shared it sounds as though for some reason she was insecure about her decisions, social status, choices, etc.... hence her attempt to make you possibly question your own.

I am in my late forties and have a best friend from 9th grade. We talk about every other week. She is truly someone I could count on in almost any circumstance. Most of the rest of my friends are casual friendships. We get together now and then. As I grow older I find I don't have much time or desire for friendships. I really enjoy my immediate family and like spending most of my time with them or simply be at home, running, reading, cooking, etc... I guess I'm an odd ball.
 
I have never consciously ended a friendship. Mine just gradually fade away. I have had different friends for different phases of my life. I have a good friend from my last job. She is the only one I talk to and the only one I care to talk to, but she is upset that the other people we worked with haven't kept up with us. She will call them every few months and then is upset they never return her calls. I don't care and never expected anyone to keep in touch, because I felt the only thing we had in common was our job and we don't have that now.

I am about to go through another phase of my life and assume I will lose some friendships because of that. I am not mad at anyone, but I am no longer going to be involved in what held us together, so I am going to assume some friendships will move along too.

OP, I hate to say this, but it sounds like she has already moved on and didn't know how to say anything. After the first couple of unreturned phone calls and uninterested lunches, I would have assumed she had moved on and left it at that. I wouldn't be nasty to her or anything, just be nice, but keep your distance too.
 
Given how long we knew each other, for quite awhile I thought that maybe she was dealing with something else that was bothering her so I did ask her stuff like "Hey, you seem distracted/angry/stressed out/etc. Is everything ok? Is there anything I can do to help?" She was pretty evasive and wouldn't give a straight answer.
 
Given how long we knew each other, for quite awhile I thought that maybe she was dealing with something else that was bothering her so I did ask her stuff like "Hey, you seem distracted/angry/stressed out/etc. Is everything ok? Is there anything I can do to help?" She was pretty evasive and wouldn't give a straight answer.

Maybe she didnt feel comfortable opening up to you.
Looking at your op and keeping in mind that she has her own perspective on the friendship, it could be that she felt you were the own judging herand thinking you are better than her.
Could she have just been happy and excited about her daughter's school but you took it as bragging and feeling better than you?
Did you unknownlingly come off as critical of the dance school and her decision to seems her daughter there?
You are very judgy of her relationship with her daughter. You've decided she was jealous of her daughter. Maybe they are both perfectly fine with their relationship and how they interact.
Did she actually say the person on the phone was cooler than you or is that just how you took it?
It seems like you've decided you totally have her number and know exactly what she is thinking in your conversations with her but maybe she feels like you were criticizing her and you were the one with the attitude of being superior.
Clearly she ended the friendship but you are under the impression that you did when you unfriended her. Maybe that's not the only thing you've gotten wrong with how this friendship came to an end.
 
I have two GF's who spend a lot of time together, (one is single with no kids, the other is married with 2 kids), they have this super annoying way of talking to each other in front of me with these annoying inside jokes. I obviously cannot follow their conversations, and when I ask they refer to me as a "FOMO", (fear of missing out)... when I found out that they actually used that phrase in the way they refer to me, I was done!

Then a good friend, (you know, one who likes me) and I went to a movie and they were like, "Oh you didn't invite us"... um no I didn't, I chose to spend my money and time with people who actually like me and want to include me in things!
 
I am about to go through another phase of my life and assume I will lose some friendships because of that. I am not mad at anyone, but I am no longer going to be involved in what held us together, so I am going to assume some friendships will move along too.

OP, I hate to say this, but it sounds like she has already moved on and didn't know how to say anything.


Wow! I could have written this. This is what I'm going through now and realize that I have gone through this during various phases of my life. I don't live in one of the most diverse & fast paced metropolitan cities in the world that offers everything there is, by ACCIDENT. One of my deep, personal values & goals is to always keep growing, expanding, and challenging myself personally, professionally and artistically. I'm constantly consciously re-evaluating my life and the directions I want to move forward. There is so much to do and explore. Especially as I have gotten my health back and have a second chance to be out living life again, I'm not going to sit around wasting this chance. Most times, that means leaving people & situations that are no longer in alignment with my life as my interests and situations change. It's not personal. We are not in the same place anymore.

Like the poem, "A Reason, Season or a Lifetime," many friendships I deeply cared about which were interests based or situational, really fit into my life for only a season. It doesn't mean the friendships had less value, or I don't still appreciate what we had during those times in my life. Yes, I felt very sad at the end of those friendships. And I can understand they just want back the person who shared all the good times with them. Surely, THAT part of me is still IN me? Right???

Uh, NO. When the interests/circumstances have changed from: "WE used to do ___ TOGETHER," to now "YOU want to still do that (which is okay,) yet I feel it in my soul that I NEED to be over THERE doing something else," we no longer intrinsically fit. We are no longer a WE. And there are only so many times one can repeat, "I'm sorry, but I'm no longer interested in that. I've moved onto other things now that you aren't into, and I'm not going back," before things turn uncomfortable or ugly because the friend just doesn't get it. :( It's best if both sides can let go with grace.


OP, it sounds like the disparity between you and your friend have become too great over time. It's not just that she has different values; if she was making plans on the phone with other people who are "cooler" than you, then she doesn't value YOU. And it sounds like you don't value the activities she values, like the dance classes and school, or how she treats her daughter. Definitely time to let go and move on.
 


Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top Bottom