Keep in mind that there are trade offs for each option. Storytellers is a buffet, so for $49, you'll get much more food than you would with the HB F! meal. You'll also get characters (assuming the buffet is done like it was last year). And you'll get to eat in a restaurant dining room. With the HB F! package, you'll get a smaller meal, but you do get great viewing for a great show. (NB The "seating" in the reserved viewing area is on the ground.) I don't think the price for the HB package would be higher on Thanksgiving because I don't think the menu changes for the holiday. So if you want traditional Thanksgiving fare, all you can eat, characters, and a more "formal" atmosphere, do Storytellers. But if you want a more casual, lighter meal with a fun show, do the HB F! package.