Hmm, I am glad you stayed at PIT versus OG Poly. Looking at the resorts you chose to buy, all are relaxing and quieter resorts. BLT was totally not our style, but that refurbishment looks wonderful and is now on our radar to try out.
If you're looking at 2B, the PIT and BLT are both great, but are you going to be insane with the hubbub at Poly/PIT? Our son loves Poly, and we wanted a MK resort, but it's honestly a little (kids everywhere) crazy at the pools/hot tubs/GCH. I feel like we're holding our breath the whole time we're there and we exhale back at Riviera (and for me, at Animal Kingdom Jambo.)
I think I'd do resale BLT and maybe sell AK if you need the funds to get more points/straighten out the use years. Although, we have all one use year, but I kind of like the idea of multiple waitlists as an option. Being limited to the two waitlists is kind of a bummer, honestly. If you're organized and feel confident you won't forget to bank, I am coming around to multiple use years/waitlists and rotating resorts depending on seasonality.
Lastly, I don't think VDH as SAP+ is a bad idea, especially with
DisneyLand Forward and the gate expansion going full steam ahead. Direct points that can be merged at Riviera/LSL/? future resorts at DL, not a bad option, especially if your folks are still in Southern CA but go into assisted living or eventually pass, but you still want a base of operations in the area that just so happens to be near an amazing attraction.
After a dozen
DVC trips and now owning six years (which I know is a drop in the bucket compared to most on here,) we're all about the resorts themselves and the room utilization. Only you know how you like to travel and what the room configuration is likely to be, but like @BrianNoble said, things do change. Sounds like a wedding, move, and tons of WDW/travel have been happening to you. IDK if kids are multigenerational trips are in the future, but all these life events change things up.
We bought planning on studios (family of four with B/G kids,) got Pixie Dusted during Covid to a 1B and never looked back. Then did an extended family trip 2B in low points season August/September and LOVED having everyone together in one apartment, basically, but with privacy at night at the beautiful Riviera 2B.
Now we're condensing our trips into baller 2Bs during peak weeks (Thanksgiving/Spring Break) because my job isn't flexible, so I have to make my time count and not have the kids miss too much time from school. Our 400 points isn't going very far with 2Bs peak weeks!
You may want more BLT points if you want the bigger rooms. Also, the PIT cheaper room views overlooking the monorail are also all in the direct line of fire for the blazing sun. I don't mind crappier views, but I do like to use my balcony. I was blinded in February when my DH and I stayed at PIT. Now I want the expensive views -- not just for the views, but to be able to use the freaking balcony with my coffee/margarita/reading my iPad in peace.
I absolutely love the PIT rooms. I think they're really well thought out (although the building hallways are a bit narrow. DH uses a
scooter on longer trips.) The PIT rooms are not an issue for the hubbub of Poly in general, but once you want to use the pool and GCH and bell services, it seems a bit chaotic. IDK if you want to tie up funds with overpriced (IMO) direct Poly points. I'd be leaning VDH/LSL for direct points in a couple years if Riviera and Poly are sold out.
)
. Still upset they wouldn't let me have churro waffles at my wedding. Mother's Day was just a couple days earlier so we danced with our parents and then we had a very expensive "friend" come dance with us and take photos. Of course I'm talking about Mickey Mouse 
. 
.
.
