Based on this small sample, it looks like many
DVC'ers have gone to AP type tickets. This is where we could use a discount. I played around with some numbers for per day costs. I did not include the DC discount but I did use the DVC UMP discount.
For 7 days,
7-day park hopper costs $46.49 per day
An UMP for 6 nights/7days with 10% off costs $42.57 per day.
The AP runs $52.85 per day (PI & water parks additional)
The PAP runs $71.02 per day
The Magical Years gives you 20 days -- 5 days per year only for 4 of the next 5 years at a cost of $37.45 per day. The cost is "okay" but the restrictions don't work for many DVC'ers.
It does lock in the cost for 5 years.
However, if you go for longer periods during a 12 month stay the AP really kicks in --
The longest Pete's list shows for an UMP is 12 nights/13 days. This costs $32.95 per day. The AP would be $28.45 and PAP $38.24. At 14 days, the APs are $26.42 and $35.51 respectively.
If you bump your visits up to say 20 days....$18.50 and $24.86!
If you add in the DC discount on the purchase of the AP and the various other perks AP's give you....discounts, special events, resort discounts, etc. they really do look to be the best deal for DVC'ers who go more than one week every 12 months.