What is your top choice?

[tippy77]

I voted for CG. I think the trick is to go AFTER the fireworks. So many tables clear out after the fireworks end so not only was the restaurant probably a bit more quiet, but we didn't have to wait long for seats by the window. We went on a night when there was the Pirate and Princess Party and there are some fireworks for that so we ended up being able to see some fireworks anyway!

 

[catgirl]

Located in Downtown Disney on the waterfront. Nautical atmosphere, mostly adult patrons when I was there at 4pm and 8:50pm. The food was great! If you are using the Dining Plan they are on it and only 1 credit.

 

[Pakey]

If I have to choose between the 4 you listed I would put them in this order:

YSH
Citricos
Ca Grill
Narcoosees

We have eaten at all 4 more than once and all within the past year. YSH and Citricos--you have a much better chance of a quieter atmosphere. Ca Grill was packed last month, we had to wait an hour past our ADR for a table--parks were empty but this place is always noisy. Narcoosees, it's just okay for food and can also be packed with kids/noisy. Better seafood at FF or bluezoo.