I chose Christian: Nondenominational, but in all honesty, I always thought Protestant meant that you were a Christian who did not follow the Catholic Church. That's how a priest explained it to me once when I was younger anyway.
Oh well, I guess that makes no real difference anyway. Why though? I had been searching for quite some time. I'd been through Catechism and I knew the Catholic Church was not for me.
I had great difficulty with asking another human (who sins too) to forgive my sins and I had a greater difficulty that they separate sin. To me, we all sin, but sin is still sin and I didn't feel one was more important than the other. I also had a really tough time accepting their idea of salvation. To die without a MORTAL sin on your soul. I just couldn't swallow that at all. To be so fearful of death at all times? Just to clarify, if you broke the 10 commandments, that's a mortal sin. There is no one alive that does not break them. The Catholic Church also makes you go through so much before you're ever even allowed to take communion. It's saying, you have to become this person before you can become a member of our group. It just didn't make sense to me!
I then started dating my husband who comes from a Christian family. His mother taught Sunday school at their church. The more I talked with my now in-laws, the more I came to conclude that I just felt I was on the right track. The message for salvation was quite clear. Accepting Christ as your savior. That's it, that's what the word says. Knowing that if you are truly saved, that Christ will make the changes in you a little at a time to make you a better person with each passing day. I also like that you were accepted from day one when you enter a Protestant church. You didn't have to do this that or the other to become a member. Christ accepts you today, exactly the way you are and he'll make the changes as he sees fit. It just felt to me, like it was the way I was suppose to go.
Now, I always believed in Christ, so I never considered any of the other religions out there.