I can't think of many that I couldn't ride over and over, except maybe IASW. Each time I think of one in my head where I can picture myself running back to the queue, I think of the next one. Peter Pan's Flight, TTA, POTC, Buzz Lightyear, Splash Mtn, Space Mtn, BTMRR, etc. And I'm not even in other parks yet!!
I must say that this coming September there are some rides that I'm really, really looking forward to riding again. DD will be 7 and has told me she wants to try HM and Splash Mtn again. The last 2 trips she's been adamant about NOT riding them. She thinks that she's ready for some "bigger kid" rides and I totally agree with her. We did a couple of smaller amusement parks in the spring and she aced everything we put her on, even saying some weren't aggressive enough. NO FEAR!!
I do agree with the OP that the riders in your elevator car enhance the ToT experience. They could totally make or break it, depending on their reactions.