Love: walking to Epcot (can also get this at BCV), standard view room availablity, Boardwalk view room availability, Keister Coaster (my kids like this slide a lot), the closeness of the Boardwalk Bakery and Flying Fish. Boardwalk entertainment.
Enjoy, but you can get similar experiences other places: pool in general, pool bar, rocking chairs on the front porch (at VWL its the fireplaces, at BCV its the beach, etc), interior hallways, availability of room service, availability of valet, Bellevue room
Not overly fond of: theming (the clown is overkill), decor (much perfer VWL). Boardwalk games, lack of "fast food."
Disadvantages to others, neutral to us: Bus transportation has been reportedly weak - we had great buses last trip, the trip before left something to be desired, and I think if you take buses, it will never be perfect. Long hallways - we've had longer hallways at AKL and WL (not the Villas) than we've ever had at BW, but its brought up enough that it could be an issue.