If they allow people to bring their pets, next thing you know people will want to bring their kids!
HAHAHA
I would be ALL for A SINGLE resort allowing pets, smoking, and all of the other things that a huge percentage of a population doesn't care to be around.
However, the housekeeping would have to be limited to check out - to prepare for the next guests.
Part of me totally understands that people LOVE their pets, and love to travel with their pets - however, people you who angry when their pets aren't welcome are entirely unreasonable. A pet is an animal - and people's tolerance for animals varies greatly.
I think if they built a resort that was like small apartments/condos each with its own fenced patio area AND an included feature would be someone that would stop by daily and police the patio area and remove any animal waste.
People would need to realize that if they wanted the convenience of smoking in their room, and the ability to bring their pets with them, and they would need to be prepared to pay for the additional features.
With that being said, what percentage of the smoking population and pet owning population would be WILLING to pay a premium price for a less than premium experience?
Would the resort create more problems that it would solve? YES - I think it would create more problems than it would solve.
Do I think Disney wants a resort on their hands that would create a ton of problems? Guest issues? Complaints? Yeah.... I really don't think Disney wants any part of dealing with any of that - that's exactly why they shed the kennel services at the parks - and Best Friends was built, and not 'Disney' branded!