dbm20th said:
And CoP was also a big billboard for GE, so I am not sure why you would look past that and worry about Disney making attractions out of their own films, which is something they also have always done. WWWD? Well he built alot of attractions based on his films, so I think the problem doesn't lie there.
I have read people saying this a lot lately, and it's starting to get old. How many did he really build based on Disney films? I can think of only 8 - Snow White, Peter Pan, Cinderella's Carousel, Dumbo, Tea Party, 20,000 Leagues, Mr. Toad and the Treehouse. If you count the castle, that's 9. I suppose some will say Tom Sawyer's Island, but that's a stretch. (I'm not sure Disney ever even made a movie about Tom Sawyer.)
Many of those (the carousel, the tea party and Dumbo for instance) are relatively thin with regard to movie tie-in. I mean, it could have been spinning anythings (not to say I don't appreciate them for what they are.) Two of them are gone already. And I wouldn't think many would consider any of the lot an E attraction.
Let's draw a cutoff line at around 1980, and look at the attractions that were in the MK by then. Consider these attractions:
Jungle Cruise; "it's a small world"; Country Bear Jamboree; Hall of Presidents; Haunted Mansion; Walt Disney World Railroad; Skyway (now gone); Tomorrowland Speedway; If You Had Wings (now gone); Pirates of the Caribbean; StarJets (now Astro Orbiter); Space Mountain; Carousel of Progress; WEDway PeopleMover; Tiki Room; Big Thunder Mountain Railroad.
That's 16 attractions, most of which are classics and still popular. If we were still getting attractions with the ratio of 1 of every 3 with movie tie-ins, I doubt there would be much complaining. That's not the case.
If we look at
ALL the new attractions just in the MK since 1998, we have:
Buzz Lightyear; Tiki Room "Under New Management"; Pooh; Magic Carpets of Aladdin; Mickey's Philharmagic; Stitch's Great Escape. That's 6 for 6 with a movie tie-in. And I'm not convinced these movies are all destined to be called "classics", which most in the first list were.
I don't think anyone is saying they mind some movie tie-ins, they're just saying, let's get back to a better balance. Surely you can see that.
By the way, it's particularly annoying when, given that the MK is pretty much out of space, new attractions take over for old ones. And guess what - like Stitch and Tiki Room, they often take over non-movie themed attractions.