We booked a 7 night Eastern cruise in October of last year. The Eastern cruise was in January. 1st seating was gone, so I was put on the wait list. When we boarded the cruise, we still didn't have 1st seating. I went to Rockin Bar D as soon as we boarded, and mentioned to them I wanted 1st seating. We were contacted about 3pm, and were told we had been moved to 1st seating. We sat with a couple from Ohio, and had a great time. I would imagine since it was just me and my wife, that made it easier for us to get moved to 1st seating. (just guessing?)