Great question, Jen! We've stayed at VB, HHI, and VGC. It's a tough call between HHI and VGC as they serve two totally different functions. VB runs a distant third for us. We love the vibe at HHI, the wealth of activities, the closeness of good restaurants, the fresh seafood, the bike/walking path system, ocean/marsh views depending on where you are on the island, and the best CMs anywhere. VGC is very reminiscent of our beloved Lodge, and it has all the amenities of a true deluxe hotel such as one of our Top 3 restaurants on Disney property (Napa Rose), a Top 5 lounge (Hearthstone), a gorgeous setting, immediate access to a park, well-appointed and quiet rooms, and an ambiance that reminds us of the iconic beauty that is our very own VWL/WL. If we were going to buy more points (we aren't), I believe we'd swing toward HHI as it offers a respite from the hubbub of the parks and exists, to us, primarily as a place to recharge our batteries while getting just a little bit of that Disney feeling.