We try to make it down to Disney about once a year, and I love finding my old favorites. I also like to see changes. I am so confused by posts that say, "we saw all the princes last year and the 3 years before and we are so ticked off we can't do that exact same thing this year." Disney never put out an official statement reading, "From this day forward - throughout time and memorium, the princes shall appear with their princesses at MNSSHP!"
I know some people are mad that they aren't going to meet Maleficent with their child who is dressed as her, but MOST people don't realize that she was to the far left at the M&M in the past, and to line up right in that spot and hope not to get trampled to meet her. The average partygoer is not going to know that, and was most likely not going to meet Maleficent under those conditions.
A lot of people (probably a lot of frequent posters to this thread!) have been intrigued by the thought of a Villain character meal for a long time. Heck, we've been talking about it on the DIS for years. Here you go, you got it! Club Villain - seems pretty dang COOL, even though it's something new and not what it was last year. Does everyone want to just rewind the tape to when they were there with Woody last year? Maybe you didn't get to go last year and all you wanted was to dance with Woody? Well they gotta keep it fresh, so you can luckily still meet him at HS. I personally think the addition of the old hag witch from Snow White meeting near the Dwarves is a really cool addition to this year's party - but it's not even a blip on the radar because there's a preoccupation for what we aren't getting.
I'm sure I'll get flamed for this, but I just wanted to highlight the fact that sometimes change is good - something new and fresh (awesome new offering, new dance party, hag!). MAYBE this will be the best MNSSHP yet - with or without the soiree. If you go expecting it to suck, it probably will.