AstroBlasters
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Oct 23, 2022
- Messages
- 6,894
We don’t know that for sure…VGC hard refurb in 2024.....
We don’t know that for sure…VGC hard refurb in 2024.....
They are two completely different products. Yes they're both in Disneyland. But the two resorts couldn't be more fundamentally different in terms of theming, location, and fanbase. I totally hear you about the ease of buying direct. VDH will also have 14 more years of contract life compared to VGC. But VGC's uniqueness and villa scarcity/availability cannot be matched, hence the high price it fetches on the resale market.
I can totally buy this. I think VDH Preferred Deluxe Studios will be widely available at 7 months. Or it's wishful thinking on my part.I'd like to tweak this based on some Riviera data that I've been looking into.
I think it's generally accepted these days that room types, in order of booking velocity (independent of inventory), are as follows:
However, this does not appear to be the case at Riviera.
- Deluxe Studios
- Tower/Duo Studios slot in here, based on limited data. Also doubt this is generally accepted.
- 2BR
- 1BR
- GV
At Riviera, it appears that 1BR, especially Standard View, may actually be more popular than 2BR (caveat: if 2BRLO is unusually popular compared to 2BR it would also cause a data artifact that would look like 1BR being popular).
I don't know what the cause of this shift in popularity is. I suspect it's a combo of the points chart and upfront price inflation, where a CPI-adjusted buy-in buys less than it used to, but this is just a guess that is slightly supported by VGF2 data.
There's an additional element I'm surprised more people aren't talking about with VDH: VDH Deluxe Studios might not be great for families. We know Duo Studios won't be, but I wouldn't be surprised if the main gripe for Deluxe Studios after years of VDH ownership boils down to:
Even DCL has tubs, so the lack of tubs in VDH Studios is really bizarre, in my opinion.
- Deluxe Studios only sleep 4
- Deluxe Studios have no tub (based on current info)
- Cheapest room that sleeps 5 or has a tub is the 1BR
Anyway, with this new-to-me information about Riviera bookings in hand and combining it with expected VDH inventory levels, here's my new tiers for VDH:
Walking only, basically year round (think AKV Value or Concierge studios):
Might need to walk, depends on season:
- Garden Duo
- Garden Deluxe
Potentially competitive at 11m, depends on season:
- 1 Bedroom
- Grand Villa (there's only 2!)
- Standard Duo
Usually available at 7m, depends on season:
- 2 Bedroom
- Standard Deluxe
- Preferred Duo
- Preferred Deluxe
That’s another reason why I’ve pared down my point needs. I don’t think we’ll be completely shut out at 7 months like VGC. That may be a gamble on my part, but also why I’m buying enough to have an 11 month advantage guaranteed sometimes and we can fill in with our WDW points when we can.I can totally buy this. I think VDH Preferred Deluxe Studios will be widely available at 7 months. Or it's wishful thinking on my part.
Agree that all the views are kind of bad. If enough others agree then the cheapest rooms will definitely go first, and that's SV Deluxe StudiosI think the question isn’t will standard studios (if they break them into views, which I’m iffy on, because all the views are kinda bad) sell out at 11 months sometimes but rather how often will they make it to 7 months, and I think the answer will be a lot, unless there’s only a small number of them (which would make the existence of them even sillier).
That is surprisingly a lot of SV studios. I wonder what the ratio is at Riviera. It's ironic that SV rooms at Riviera are not only cheaper in points, but better in actual views. I don't ever hope to book a SV studio or 2BR at Riviera at 7 months.Agree that all the views are kind of bad. If enough others agree then the cheapest rooms will definitely go first, and that's SV Deluxe Studios
There might be times of year where a trickle of SV Deluxe Studios make it to 7m, but I wouldn't count on it. Based on floor plans there will be ~76 SV vs. ~170 Preferred View Deluxe Studios.
That’s a guess based on your assessment of view quality, right?Based on floor plans there will be ~76 SV vs. ~170 Preferred View Deluxe Studios
Riviera will probably be 67 SV vs. 119 PV whenever it's fully declared. 47 SV and 79 PV are in inventory now.That is surprisingly a lot of SV studios. I wonder what the ratio is at Riviera. It's ironic that SV rooms at Riviera are not only cheaper in points, but better in actual views. I don't ever hope to book a SV studio or 2BR at Riviera at 7 months.
Yeah, simply based on whether it has a pool view. Can be rephrased as "76 with no pool view and 170 with a pool view".That’s a guess based on your assessment of view quality, right?
The SV vs PV breakdown was finalized when they published their launch documents. I don’t have it handy but it’s published in this forum somewhere. If you wanted to lose your eyesight and your sanity you could take the descriptions of each “unit” from their published information and calculate the points and thus the views of each one, but someone else here did that in 2019..Riviera will probably be 67 SV vs. 119 PV whenever it's fully declared. 47 SV and 79 PV are in inventory now
I have the 67 (9ded, 58LO) vs 119 (29ded, 90LO) in my spreadsheet but I forget the provenance of it, hence the "probably" qualifier. I should track down where I got the info. Should be close. I'm positive of the 47/79 in inventory currently though.The SV vs PV breakdown was finalized when they published their launch documents. I don’t have it handy but it’s published in this forum somewhere. If you wanted to lose your eyesight and your sanity you could take the descriptions of each “unit” from their published information and calculate the points and thus the views of each one, but someone else here did that in 2019..
Just got my resale contract loaded and now in the market for direct points. My guide (CA licensed) already knows and reached out to me today. I said we are waiting on DLT pricing announcement. We are adding RIV, VGF, or DLT for sure… @RoseGold argument for Disneyland was so convincing I’m holding off my add-on-itis until then.
Are you asking about upfront buy-in cost per point? Or points per night cost?I’m in a similar quandary. Our home resort is VGC and we had decided to forego adding on, then we went to Disney World in March and took a DVC tour. Now I really want to add on - the guide was strongly pitching VGF, which appeals to us. But Disneyland Tower is still looming.
Does everyone generally think Disneyland Tower will cost more than VGF? We nixed Riviera; even though we loved it, the resale restrictions give us pause.
Are you asking about upfront buy-in cost per point? Or points per night cost?
The base cost per point will very likely be the same at all actively sold resorts (AUL, RIV, VGF, and VDH). That may or may not increase before VDH goes on sale.Upfront buy-in cost per point….if we bought VGF, we’d get the Disney Visa incentive……for the amount of points we’d purchase, it would cost us around $214/point.
I think it’s very likely (no guarantees!) that Disneyland Hotel DVC will launch its presale with a lower NET price per point (with incentives) than VGF has today for current DVC owners. What the general public will get will probably depend on how the DVC owner presale goes.I’m in a similar quandary. Our home resort is VGC and we had decided to forego adding on, then we went to Disney World in March and took a DVC tour. Now I really want to add on - the guide was strongly pitching VGF, which appeals to us. But Disneyland Tower is still looming.
Does everyone generally think Disneyland Tower will cost more than VGF? We nixed Riviera; even though we loved it, the resale restrictions give us pause.
The more sales continue on at their recent slow pace, the more likely this is, I think.I think it’s very likely (no guarantees!) that Disneyland Hotel DVC will launch its presale with a lower NET price per point (with incentives) than VGF has today for current DVC owners. What the general public will get will probably depend on how the DVC owner presale goes.
I agree, I think it’ll be quite a while before 7months wont be available.That’s another reason why I’ve pared down my point needs. I don’t think we’ll be completely shut out at 7 months like VGC.
I think it’s very likely (no guarantees!) that Disneyland Hotel DVC will launch its presale with a lower NET price per point (with incentives) than VGF has today for current DVC owners. What the general public will get will probably depend on how the DVC owner presale goes.
I know…. It’s just still that I can’t buy the exact number of points I want/use year and the ease of buying direct does appeal to me more. I loved getting my points immediately and just doing a few docusigns and paying. As you may have guessed from my prior post, patience isn’t one of my strongest areasbut if the perfect VGC contract came up, I’d think about it. A few pretty close to perfect ones came up a while back and I thought about it a bit, but struggled to justify the difference in price from what I think VDH will be and they got snapped up while I was thinking on it.
They are two completely different products. Yes they're both in Disneyland. But the two resorts couldn't be more fundamentally different in terms of theming, location, and fanbase. I totally hear you about the ease of buying direct. VDH will also have 14 more years of contract life compared to VGC. But VGC's uniqueness and villa scarcity/availability cannot be matched, hence the high price it fetches on the resale market. I highly doubt VDH will compete with VGC in the resale market, especially if it will have resale restrictions, which is highly likely.
Now that I think about it, I think it's possible that DVD would deliberately delay VGC's refurbishment for as long as possible to boost VDH sales, which is in direct competition with VGC resale. As long as VGC stays old and dingy, it gives VDH a slight edge. I'm no conspiracy theorist but I can't look past Disney. Oh hell, who am I kidding. I AM totally a conspiracy theorist! lol.
I’m not going to bank on staying in a refurbished VGC room until 2025I'm just curious what the perfect VGC contract would be for you?
It worries me that they haven't officially announced the VGC refurb. I hope it's still going to be 2024. It definitely won't be done before our June 2024 trip but hopefully by our December 2025 one it will be finished!