I agree. I was at Ruby Tuesday yesterday with my Twilight book (only one ral friend in town so I'm always by myself). The waitress noticed it and started talking to me about the series. This happens to me all the time.
Anyway, we got to talking about the new director and I was saying that I have some high hopes. Twilight was good considering the budget, but Catherine Hardwicke is a teen in an adult's body. The one thing that I think makes these books appealing to such a wide audience is that Bella and Edward aren't your typical teenagers. Over and over again it is emphasized how Bella is very mature for her age (My mom says I was born middle aged and get older every year), and while Edward does tend to overreact, he is still not a typical teenager. I did not get that at all from the movie. The meadow scene especially was just way too angsty and whiny for me. In the book when he says "as if you could outrun me, as if you could fight me off" he is whispering it. It is a much more intimate moment than how it was portrayed in the movie. Honestly, the whole meadow scene in the movie pissed me off.
The same thing with the fight scene. That is probably my favorite scene in the book and it was a complete 180. I didn't like that Carlisle had to pull Edward off of James because in the book Edward immediately goes to Bella. That is his concern. And it makes no sense to me that Carlisle is okay with the others killing James but not Edward. What's up with that? The other part is when Carlisle is telling him to stop. Yes, in the book Edward thought he wasn't going to be able to stop, but he did it without Carlisle or Alice's help. To me this is a huge distinction and really changes his character.
I know that is kind of nitpicky, but things liike that just bug me. I don't mind changes except when they change the personality of the characters themselves, and to me that is what Twilight did in some ways. (Don't get me wrong, still loved the movie, but I'm hoping that a new director can take it in a different direction.) I admit, it will be hard not to have New Moon be very angsty given the plotline, but I'm hoping to get out of this woe is me teenager stuff that was so prevalent in the first movie and really showcase some more depth to the characters.
Dude, I hear ya... I saw it again today (3rd time) and I think I should have left it at two. I was freaking out the first time, the second was calmer and smoother, but this time I had time to re-nitpik. LOL Ah well.....
One thing (of the few ... but I don't want to bash) I noticed that have probably already been discussed:
1)Why don't Jasper and Alice "sparkle" when they're at the airport in Arizona or around town?
I forget the answer to this question though I know it's been answered before.
2) I think that in Edwards room, on his book case, is the set of antlers that is seen during the "when my ancestors were descended from wolves" story that Jacob Black tells Bella while walking on the beach... they flashback to the Cullens hunting and it looks like there are antlers ripped off of the "prey". I hadn't noticed that before and this time, like i said, I think I noticed them on Edwards bookshelf. Kinda cute!
3) I think after all the parodies I've watched that the special effects just look so much worse (I really tried to stay awy from them, too! - Say it... SANTA CLAUS!). Blech.
Oh well.. the enchantment wasn't meant to last forever. I am eagerly awating the next installment (but first, of course, is the DVD of extra's!) You know what... I may not even see it again even on DVD before I see New Moon. I want it to settle into memories... maybe they will be kinder.
Don't get me wrong, EDWARD IS STILL HOT and I had SO MUCH FUN with the movie and all the side trips (which I have more scheduled in April for touring the shooting locations.. it's with the Twilightmoms.com and should be really fuN!). And I love the books. But man...that movie was pretty bad in parts. Even still, I am a fan. I will always be.
The person who went with me to see Twilight today said, "There was a lot of close-up's of Edward's eyes... dun dun DUNNNNNNN"
