Tutto Italia vs. Tony's - any comparison whatsoever?

[tfoster]

We haven't tried either one and I'm curious as to what people think.

 

[melisandes]

Well I can tell you that I hate Tonys. I walked out because they took forever to take our order, were generally rude, and the menu just plain sucked. I have not been able to get into Italy since the change over. I loved it when it was alfredos. That does not mean much now.

 

[rsbuxt]

Well I can tell you that I hate Tonys. I walked out because they took forever to take our order, were generally rude, and the menu just plain sucked. I have not been able to get into Italy since the change over. I loved it when it was alfredos. That does not mean much now.

Hi

I've only eaten at Tony's once and wished I'd walked out before I ate - terrible food!

Rich

 

[spetersen]

We ate at both in September. Tutto was outstanding....Tony's was ok. I will say Tony's was better than I remembered it but there is no comparison between Tutto and there.

 

[ennisb]

Well we have done both and they can't be compared not based on food is just totally different places. It's like compare Olive Garden to a gourmet Italian restaraunt.

I think both are good place to eat if you keep in mind where you are eating. Tony's good food like the local pizza place or fast food italian.

Tutto will get you a better food and associated service.

 

[webray]

Tony's is horrible. Head to Tutto, or head over to Swan Resort and eat at IL Mulino.

 

[BCV23]

No comparison...Tutto is heads above Tony's.

We broke down and tried Tony's again about a year ago. As someone else said, it was better than it used to be but...... We did have a fantastic server though.

 

[Minniemama350]

We ate at both in September. Tutto was outstanding....Tony's was ok. I will say Tony's was better than I remembered it but there is no comparison between Tutto and there.

I totally agree!! We'd take Tutto over Tony's ANY day!

 

[GoofySon'sMom]

I totally agree!! We'd take Tutto over Tony's ANY day!

Me, too. We have given Tony's several tries and always been disappointed. Long wait times, bad service, mediocre food. Probably won't be going back, at least for dinner. But Tutto was fabulous! We had an excellent server and a really great meal.

 

[traviesojmt]

Well, I am just joining the choir at this point, but we loved Tutto Italia. We actually ate there twice on our last trip. We have eaten at Tony's once and really weren't that impressed.

 

[tfoster]

Well, it looks like I made the right decision. I've never been to either. At one point, we were going to go to Tony's for dinner. I just couldn't get excited about it, so I ended up cancelling and making an ADR for a different night at Tutto Italia's. Ever since, I've been really excited. I was wondering if I was onto something or just being weird!!

 

[chocovrdmicears]

Tony's was AWEFUL.
Tutto was DELIGHTFUL.

NO comparison!

 

[moray26]

Okay, just to be on the flip side, I'm going to disagree with everybody about Tony's...

I LOVE TONY'S!!!

I've been there twice, and each time the server made a minor error in my favor. I always go mid-afternoon (around parade time) and have excellent service. The first time I went I got the 1/2 panini and soup or salad special. I ordered the soup, but when the waiter came out he had the soup and salad. He told me he had made a mistake and forgotten I had ordered soup, so he brough both. SWEET! And the food was delicious.

Second time I ordered spaghetti with Italian sausage. Once again, delicious food and fast service. My waitress was funny though, she walks out with my plate of spaghetti and looks down at it and says, "you ordered sausage, didn't you?" sets the plate down, and walks away. She had brought me meatballs instead of sausage, but I wasn't feeling particularly picky, so I didn't say anything. But in 2 minutes she was back with a side dish of sausage and marinara...I couldn't believe how much sausage and meatball I had to eat!!!

So I say give both Tony's and Tutto a chance. I LOVE the Farfalle - Bowtie pasta, Italian prosciutto ham, peas, parmesian cream - at Tutto.

 

[MickeyNicki]

Tonys and Mama Melrose are very similiar, both like Olive Garden...good and cheap

Tutto and Il Mulino are very similar but Il Mulino is better that Tutto...more of an upscale Italian restaurant

We will eat at all 4 but our favorite is IM

 

[B-Ride]

We haven't tried either one and I'm curious as to what people think.

The only thing they have in common is that they are both at Disney World.

 

[wdwmickey]

DD (14) loved Tony's, but, all we had was Bianca flatbread and dessert. We are looking forward to Tutto's this time around.

 

[disneygirlinnj]

Tony's isn't horrible...it's just like Olive Garden or Macaroni Grill... not real Italian.

Tutto is authentic Italian that we LOVE.

Ate at both a few weeks ago and while Tony's was good for a normal meal... Tutto was amazing. We actually changed our ADRs around and ate there twice!

 

[2cats1kid]

Haven't eaten at Tony's but did Tutto last trip. OMG that pasta with the ham, peas, parmesan and cream that a PP mentioned is heaven on a plate. I'd have licked my plate if I could! DD had the chicken and said it was her best chicken ever.

We mean to try some new restaurants next trip but I am very tempted to schedule Tutto again just to get that pasta dish!