Loving your trip report! We were on the same cruise and loved it as much - also NYC winter break. Our cabin was right near yours, muster K, same dinner rotation and we did that fun tour in the sea day - you were the one who knew all the answers right? My husband was the barefoot one. I wish we had Paolo though. We have done the Grand Slam but also hoping for the Wonder next February. We were so happy we made it to Castaway! Thanks for letting us relive it so soon, as we sit in cold NYC back to work and school!