I tried Tony's last week and found it to be absolutely horrible. The shrimp scampi was the worst I've ever had in my life. The sundried tomatoes were poor quality and almost seemed rotten. I love sundried tomatoes and these must have been the cheapest Disney could buy. The asparagus did not taste like it was grilled, but instead had a fake smoked taste to it. The red sauce used on the lasagna tasted like cheap jar sauce. I would equate the restaurant quality to be equal to a school cafeteria. I spoke to the chef about the meal and he did not seemed surprised by what I told him.
I'm guessing this is how someplace like Olive Garden would be - mass produced and low quality. But it was a far cry from being close to good Italian food. Anyone who eats homemade or at real Italian restaurants will be disappointed. I recommend going to a different place to dine.