We have eaten at both. We've always had a good meal at Tony's, but we prefer Plaza. Yes, it may not be as much "bang for your buck" with the dining plan, but after all the "heavy" meals we have at other restaurants (LeCellier, Biergarten, Boma, Crystal Palace, etc.), we enjoy a simpler meal of a burger, reuben, grilled chicken or whatever with a nice, cold chocolate shake and a great hot fudge sundae! The Plaza has become a MUST DO for us every trip.