The Turf Club vs Captain's Grille

[ulcards99]

I saw today that AP holders get 30% off through end of September at a few restaurants. The Turf Club and Captain's Grille menus look the most interesting to us. I read Captain's Grille was in a new location and the entire menu isn't actually available during this time. Anyone have experience with Captain's Grille lately? I've also read great reviews on The Turf Club.

Which one would you do? We are all adults, so no kids to consider for this trip. TIA!!!

 

[Kirk]

I did the Turf Club long ago staying at the SS and don't remember it. I would have remembered if it rang my bell or sank my ship so must have been a 3/4 star. A couple in our party will be staying there in 2 weeks so I may give it another try. I just made ADRs at Captain's Grill before an Illuminations Cruise I have 8/8 after Dan Murphy pointed out that same discount... I will tell you after that

(Still room on that cruise if anyone wants to tag along.)

 

[Hopefully]

The Captain's Grille is being refurbished and repurposed. It is temporarily located at Ariel's in the Beach Club Resort. There is a full menu, with the exception of the breakfast buffet.
We ate at the Turf Club a few years ago. We thought it was very good

 

[jimmytammy]

I wish I could give good reviews on both, but can't in all honesty.

 

[bobbiwoz]

I usually enjoy Turf Club, but my last lamb dish was awful. It has been 2 years, and I am giving it another chance. I do enjoy Captains Grille.