The Official Harper's Island thread starts 4/9/09....

[Metro West]

Didnt she say that the Sheriff took her????? I think he put her there for safe keeping.

That's what I thought too. I think Madison was told to say the Sheriff took her...just like Richard told her to tell the Sheriff a lie a few episodes back about his whereabouts. Here's an interesting idea: Maybe Abby isn't the child the journal spoke of. Maybe Jimmy or Shane is the child Sara had with Wakefield. Maybe she gave the child up for adoption and no one knows it. Just a guess.

 

[wall*e2008]

That's what I thought too. I think Madison was told to say the Sheriff took her...just like Richard told her to tell the Sheriff a lie a few episodes back about his whereabouts. Here's an interesting idea: Maybe Abby isn't the child the journal spoke of. Maybe Jimmy or Shane is the child Sara had with Wakefield. Maybe she gave the child up for adoption and no one knows it. Just a guess.

The love child is not Abby but another. There was no mention of the sex of the child and the time the child was born. This could have all happened before the Sheriff and Sara had.

 

[Metro West]

The love child is not Abby but another. There was no mention of the sex of the child and the time the child was born. This could have all happened before the Sheriff and Sara had.

Yup and based on behavior, I would say Shane has some issues!

 

[chellewashere]

Im beginning to think its not Abby who is the love child either. Seems to easy now for her to be the kid. I think Madison does know who kidnapped her and is enjoying "playing the game with the person" but it would appear that it has to be someone that she knows. I am beginning to think its Henry. It has to be someone who worked on the island. To know all those tunnels and how to get your way around it...but then again it did seem like the room that Madison was in someone has been living in it which makes me think Jimmy. If it turns out to be Jimmy I am gonna be so sad cause well lets face it hes just a cutie!!! What number was that 8 of 13??

 

[karajeboo]

I also agree that it's not Abby that's the love child. Notice how the diary never says "son" or "daughter"? Just says "child." I think that is to get us to assume it's Abby. And yes, funny how Maggie just popped into this episode with a much larger part, and very creepy at times, too........

 

[anniemae]

Hmmmmmmmm. Now I'm wondering if Jimmy is Wakefields son. That would make Jimmy and Abby half-siblings and maybe that is why Abby's dad did not want her and Jimmy to be together when they were young.

 

[browneyes106]

I think there will be some kind of twist to the Wakefield's child part. Maybe he didn't have a child with Abby's mom but he did with another woman.

 

[Metro West]

Here's an idea...how about Maggie...the manager of The Candlewick Inn & wedding planner? She could be Wakefield's wife or sister finishing what he started.

 

[Sherlee]

If Jimmy was Wakefield's child would Abby's mom have let her go off "camping" with him in the flashback a couple of weeks ago? Unless she did not know who adopted her child.

 

[Veronica Lodge]

I am starting to think Henry and Jimmy are the killers.

 

[Veronica Lodge]

I am starting to think Henry and Jimmy are the killers.

 

[chellewashere]

I am starting to think Henry and Jimmy are the killers.

Cant be Jimmy hes too cute I like the idea of the owner of the inn being the sister or wife finishing that sounds good, but I think it has to be 2 people and one has to live on the island in the room under the chadwick where madison was found.

 

[karajeboo]

Nope, per CBS it is only ONE killer.

 

[Metro West]

I saw on a website that has a "death chart" of the show who is going to die tonight and it's going to be a BIG surprise...

I'm not saying anything else right now.

 

[anniemae]

Awwwwwwwwwww come on Metro West, you have to give a link to the spoiler site, or write it in white so we have to highlight it!!! I love spoilers!!!

I know it's on in 30 minutes, but I have to know. (plus I can make a bet with DH about who dies on the show and I can actually win! Just kidding!)

 

[anniemae]

5 more minutes!!! I have been googling like crazy. Apparently the episode already aired in Canada, so they are posting spoilers.

 

[harleyquinn]

So far good! That wasn't the sheriff....someone please kill madison!

 

[Maridw]

Awwwwwwwwwww come on Metro West, you have to give a link to the spoiler site, or write it in white so we have to highlight it!!! I love spoilers!!!

I know it's on in 30 minutes, but I have to know. (plus I can make a bet with DH about who dies on the show and I can actually win! Just kidding!)

Check out Wikipedia. That is where a death chart that shows who has already been killed and in what episode.

 

[Metro West]

Check out Wikipedia. That is where a death chart that shows who has already been killed and in what episode.

Kill joy!

 

[chellewashere]

I have to say I was really disappointed by last night episode...didnt see Wakefield at all only good thing is that there might be a second killer (so much for the channel saying there is only 1). Cant be Jimmy why would the sheriff make a deal to keep him alive with Maggie?? So now it could be someone that is in the "in crowd" who I at first was thinking NO since they kept saying only one killer...So c'mon who has thoughts on the 2nd killer??? Has got to be Makefields kid, wish someone would read the damn diary that would tell you all. And I agree will someone just do away with Madison no child should be that damn freaky!!