The 2008 American Idol Thread.....

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ryan scared me. I thought the bad news for Jason C. was that he was leaving. Whew!

I'm not upset about who left last night, so no comments. I thought Simon was looking like Bullwinkle myself :confused3
 
I am sorry but that is not rolling her eyes...I politely disagree. Rolling of eyes they almost roll back in there head. to me it looks like she was trying to see someone in the audience then brought her eyes to the judges. I have seen some eyes rolling on this show and this is not it.....its a shame yall are judging her but one little look. I think she is hot but she should have went home based on her performance this week thats all. I still maintain she has a good voice but will get voted out way too early because she "rolled her eyes" and the womens movement didnt like it. JMHO if now Noriega rolls his eyes. you wanna see eye rolling watch him. I seed David A do the same thing but he has a cheesy grin and is so called "innocent" so he will go a long way. Judge the singing and performance....oh I forgot its not a singing competiton my bad....:confused3

Okay, proof positive that Dan is so BLONDE BLIND that he doesn't recognize attitude.... :laughing:

Come on, man... Diva Danny has been raked over the coals for his attitude and I've been calling David A a doofus and a goofball since the beginning. And they're BOTH attractive people. Attitude, imho, is 85% of life, and a bad attitude makes a person completely ugly in my eyes.


It has NOTHING to do with the "women's movement", it is a result of bad parenting, and a spoiled reaction because no one taught her how to graciously accept criticism. That comes with maturity and dignity.

I've been a beautiful person all my life and got lots of what I call "pretty prejudice" so I don't give it out. If this girl acted like a lady, she would garner more respect and probably wouldn't have been the recipient of the third lowest votes. Read the AI and VFTW boards, they are disgusted with her. She'd better come up with a way to attract voters or she will be only alive in your signature and nowhere else.

Love ya, don't change! :wave:
 
I am sorry but that is not rolling her eyes...I politely disagree. Rolling of eyes they almost roll back in there head. to me it looks like she was trying to see someone in the audience then brought her eyes to the judges. I have seen some eyes rolling on this show and this is not it.....its a shame yall are judging her but one little look. I think she is hot but she should have went home based on her performance this week thats all. I still maintain she has a good voice but will get voted out way too early because she "rolled her eyes" and the womens movement didnt like it. JMHO if now Noriega rolls his eyes. you wanna see eye rolling watch him. I seed David A do the same thing but he has a cheesy grin and is so called "innocent" so he will go a long way. Judge the singing and performance....oh I forgot its not a singing competiton my bad....:confused3


I'm with you on this one Dan...I have 3 teenage daughters and they can eyeroll with the best if them, that is not an eyeroll. To me it looks more like looking away to control emotions(like crying) from being told your song stunk. I guess it is in the eye of the beholder how they take it though.
 

I've been a beautiful person all my life and got lots of what I call "pretty prejudice" so I don't give it out. If this girl acted like a lady, she would garner more respect and probably wouldn't have been the recipient of the third lowest votes. Read the AI and VFTW boards, they are disgusted with her. She'd better come up with a way to attract voters or she will be only alive in your signature and nowhere else.

:lmao: :lmao: Come on Robin, part of being "gracious", like you said, isn't going around tootin' your own horn while putting down a random pretty girl ;)

I'm with you on this one Dan...I have 3 teenage daughters and they can eyeroll with the best if them, that is not an eyeroll. To me it looks more like looking away to control emotions(like crying) from being told your song stunk. I guess it is in the eye of the beholder how they take it though.

I'm not a fan of Kady but I never got the "attitude" thing from her either :confused3 She's young and standing up there on national television and taking that kind of criticism at any age has got to be hard! She just looks like she's trying to hold back her emotions, and kudos to her for keeping it together!
 
:lmao: :lmao: Come on Robin, part of being "gracious", like you said, isn't going around tootin' your own horn while putting down a random pretty girl ;)



I'm not a fan of Kady but I never got the "attitude" thing from her either :confused3 She's young and standing up there on national television and taking that kind of criticism at any age has got to be hard! She just looks like she's trying to hold back her emotions, and kudos to her for keeping it together!


Watch Kady in the crowd shots and she always has that snotty snear on her face. Sorry, she is a snot. She is going to blow a gasket when she loses next week.
 
I have to agree with the very few on this thread.....I like Kady and having substitute taught mainly teenagers for the past 20 years, I don't see her facial moves as attitude at all. Believe me, I've seen a LOT of attitude!! :rotfl:

Besides, I think she has a very nice singing voice. :)
 
:lmao: :lmao: Come on Robin, part of being "gracious", like you said, isn't going around tootin' your own horn while putting down a random pretty girl ;)

Yo, homegirl, you know me better than that.

I'm not TOOTIN any horn, I was told by Mr. Dan that the "woman's movement" was the cause of my angst. I just wanted to point out that it was not a petty thing, I was looking at it as a mother not hardly as a peer, and I know what that's like because I've dealt with it all my life. That's not a brag, that's a sad fact. Sorry you took it that way.

Needless to say, everyone perceives things the way they perceive them. No one is right or wrong. That is why there are so many different TYPES on AI, the producers want to please everyone... well, everyone but black women because they NEVER cast classically good looking black men... uh, NEVER. Ruben was adorable but he wasn't Denzel! :goodvibes
 
Perez Hilton found a pretty perfect image of Travolta to compare with Jason Castro :rotfl:
seppppbirth__oPt.jpg
 
Has anyone been able to find mp3's of David A's version of Heaven that he sang during Hollywood week? Ditto that for David H's Love the One You're With. They're not even available on ITunes. :(
 
I am really surprised about Alaina. I said last week I didn't like her, but she actually was pretty decent. I felt bad for her and thought she sang her final performance fairly well.

Thought it was cute how David A. was crying when Alexandrea got voted off and then she went over to hug him. :goodvibes
 
Watch Kady in the crowd shots and she always has that snotty snear on her face. Sorry, she is a snot. She is going to blow a gasket when she loses next week.

I doubt she'll blow a gasket. You could tell that when she was standing there with Alaina that she was ready to go this week.
 
Okay, proof positive that Dan is so BLONDE BLIND that he doesn't recognize attitude.... :laughing:

Come on, man... Diva Danny has been raked over the coals for his attitude and I've been calling David A a doofus and a goofball since the beginning. And they're BOTH attractive people. Attitude, imho, is 85% of life, and a bad attitude makes a person completely ugly in my eyes.


It has NOTHING to do with the "women's movement", it is a result of bad parenting, and a spoiled reaction because no one taught her how to graciously accept criticism. That comes with maturity and dignity.

I've been a beautiful person all my life and got lots of what I call "pretty prejudice" so I don't give it out. If this girl acted like a lady, she would garner more respect and probably wouldn't have been the recipient of the third lowest votes. Read the AI and VFTW boards, they are disgusted with her. She'd better come up with a way to attract voters or she will be only alive in your signature and nowhere else.

Love ya, don't change! :wave:

Robin now you are saying she has bad parents....come on thats hitting a little below the belt dont you think...

I like the Blonde Blind comment...as hot as I think she is I can still see past that and say she didnt sing well. I will not let a eye roll or a look cloud my judgement of what is really going on on stage. Is she the best singer I doubt it does she have attidude? based on her interviews no I dont think she does. fact is these 4 blondes have gotten a raw deal from all the bad mouthing on this and other boards and to judge them cause they are Blonde is totally wrong. Just like judging based on skin color. just wrong. JMHO
 
Yo, homegirl, you know me better than that.

I'm not TOOTIN any horn, I was told by Mr. Dan that the "woman's movement" was the cause of my angst. I just wanted to point out that it was not a petty thing, I was looking at it as a mother not hardly as a peer, and I know what that's like because I've dealt with it all my life. That's not a brag, that's a sad fact. Sorry you took it that way.

Needless to say, everyone perceives things the way they perceive them. No one is right or wrong. That is why there are so many different TYPES on AI, the producers want to please everyone... well, everyone but black women because they NEVER cast classically good looking black men... uh, NEVER. Ruben was adorable but he wasn't Denzel! :goodvibes

Wasnt it last season they had the young muscular black guy. I think it was last season. Fact is I dont think there are as many young black guys trying out...kinda like Hockey just not there thing. thats how I see it anyway.
 
Wasnt it last season they had the young muscular black guy. I think it was last season. Fact is I dont think there are as many young black guys trying out...kinda like Hockey just not there thing. thats how I see it anyway.

All I remember is Brandon and he was aiiiight... not really great looking, but kind of ok. I'd still pick Ruben over him!

Thousands tried out in Atlanta last year, including my sister's nephews, who could sing every man in the top 24 under the TABLE.


BTW, my ex Michael is a hockey player! He's from Canada. I remember waiting for him after the game and every person who came out said "Michael will be out in a few"....:laughing: ... I stopped one and said "I'm waiting for SCOTT." He almost FAINTED!!:rotfl2:
 
Watch Kady in the crowd shots and she always has that snotty snear on her face. Sorry, she is a snot. She is going to blow a gasket when she loses next week.

I don't think so. Last night you could tell she thought she was the one going and she was just smiling and nodding at Ryan. Her face is a little... "squished" so maybe that's what you see as a snotty snear? I've just never seen it and don't get all the bashing :confused3
 
All I remember is Brandon and he was aiiiight... not really great looking, but kind of ok. I'd still pick Ruben over him!

Thousands tried out in Atlanta last year, including my sister's nephews, who could sing every man in the top 24 under the TABLE.


BTW, my ex Michael is a hockey player! He's from Canada. I remember waiting for him after the game and every person who came out said "Michael will be out in a few"....:laughing: ... I stopped one and said "I'm waiting for SCOTT." He almost FAINTED!!:rotfl2:

Not Brandon...This guy was almost bald and was muscular....light skin and always looked like hi eyes were closed....what was his name....Oh I like Brandon last season he is still the only person i have ever voted for on this show
 
Status
Not open for further replies.















Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top