The 2008 American Idol Thread.....

[Lynn5700]

I love all the David's lol!!!

 

[nannerbadnanner]

I think the 3 Davids and Chikezie were the best. They could start a band by that name.....3 Davids and Chikezie!

 

[bicker]

...wasn't Danny on the cover of the August 1972 Tiger Beat magazine??!!?!

What, as a sperm or an ova?

 

[Obi-Wan Pinobi]

David A did okay, but it seems a bit of a cop out that he skipped the opening lines "Imagine there's no heaven". What especially seemed a cop out was his response to Randy's question about skipping the lines saying the 3rd was his favorite.

Okay, David, you're a Mormon. That's fine. If you want to skip the line for religious reasons, that's fine. At least admit it instead of being afraid of alienating people.

 

[kimmar067]

I think the 3 Davids and Chikezie were the best. They could start a band by that name.....3 Davids and Chikezie!

...

 

[DeterminedOne]

oh and there we go again with the "gee golly whiz, mister" response.

I think it's sweet - shows his innocence.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

Sorry no WOW out of the guys tonight....

Bring on the girls....Only thing I had to look at tonight was Noriega...

Did I just say that?????........OMG

are you saying none of their looks "WOW"ed you, or their performances??

 

[cruiserkaren]

I think the 3 Davids and Chikezie were the best. They could start a band by that name.....3 Davids and Chikezie!

 

[Nancy]

Sorry no WOW out of the guys tonight....

Bring on the girls....Only thing I had to look at tonight was Noriega...

Did I just say that?????........OMG

Dan...do we need to start to worry about you????

David A did okay, but it seems a bit of a cop out that he skipped the opening lines "Imagine there's no heaven". What especially seemed a cop out was his response to Randy's question about skipping the lines saying the 3rd was his favorite.

Okay, David, you're a Mormon. That's fine. If you want to skip the line for religious reasons, that's fine. At least admit it instead of being afraid of alienating people.

I thought it was kinda sucky that Randy asked that question. I'm sure he knew darn well why he didn't sing it.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I think it's sweet - shows his innocence.

to me it's annoying and will just get worse as the weeks go by.

 

[NHAnn]

Wife: "I didn't think Yoko was letting anyone have rights to perform that song."

Blake Lewis sang it last season, I think on that episode that they did to benefit world hunger, and didn't vote anyone off.

 

[dolphindan1]

I think it's sweet - shows his innocence.

Innocence....HA...17 years old he knows exactly what he is doing....but he is smart in doing it...I think....When I was 17 well lets just say I knew how to play people and girls...Player....

 

[Minnie_me]

Seriously, tears? That's a bit much.

Music moves me. I've never been to a Broadway show where I haven't absolutely SOBBED, and I can't control it. I love "Imagine", love John Lennon (I was suspended in High school for putting the flag at half staff when he was killed), I didn't want to hear David A. sing it (and potentially ruin it). So I sat there, expecting not to like it, and the tears started.

It was a powerful performance by a brilliantly gifted young man.

 

[disneynutt1225]

...wasn't Danny on the cover of the August 1972 Tiger Beat magazine??!!?!

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

David A did okay, but it seems a bit of a cop out that he skipped the opening lines "Imagine there's no heaven". What especially seemed a cop out was his response to Randy's question about skipping the lines saying the 3rd was his favorite.

Okay, David, you're a Mormon. That's fine. If you want to skip the line for religious reasons, that's fine. At least admit it instead of being afraid of alienating people.

ITA, he should have admitted to why he skipped the lines instead of ignoring avoiding the question. is he ashamed of it or something??

 

[kimmar067]

What, as a sperm or an ova?

...oooops, mah bad, that was Danny Partridge.....

 

[dolphindan1]

are you saying none of their looks "WOW"ed you, or their performances??

Neither, either, both....just an hour and half I will never get back

 

[sandramaac]

please please please vote off Danny Noriega he is just too strange perhaps that he/she thing going on it doesn't work at all

Danny Archuleta so wonderful

Luke very cute though

 

[dolphindan1]

Dan...do we need to start to worry about you????



I thought it was kinda sucky that Randy asked that question. I'm sure he knew darn well why he didn't sing it.

not quite yet....

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

Innocence....HA...17 years old he knows exactly what he is doing....but he is smart in doing it...I think....When I was 17 well lets just say I knew how to play people and girls...Player....

i was thinking the EXACT same thing. "innocence?? he's 17! what innocence??"