On our May '08 trip, we were on the Deluxe Dining Plan and we enjoyed it VERY MUCH! We are big-time foodies, so it was great to get to eat at all those restaurants. However, it really is TOO much food. I wish Disney would come up with a package between the basic dining and deluxe dining. I would like for it to include 3 meals, like the Deluxe currently does, only you would have a choice of either an appetizer OR dessert, but not both....and this option would cost less than the current Deluxe plan.
Anyway, we were able to try many great restaurants, and I thought it would serve me well to give each of them a grade for future reference. So, here goes:
California Grill - A. What can I say? We had very high expectations of this restaurant and it DID NOT disappoint! By far the best sushi I've ever had anywhere, and the Banana Butterscotch Buzz dessert was the greatest dessert ever. If I only go back to one restaurant on our next trip, it would be this one.
Liberty Tree Tavern - B+. The food was really good, and it hit the spot for lunch after a morning full of activity at the Magic Kingdom. I would consider eating here again for lunch on our next trip, but we may try something different like Crystal Palace.
Tony's Town Square - B. DS11 LOVED this restaurant. I really liked the atmosphere and our service was really good. The food was good, but not great. It was on par with an Olive Garden or something similar. DS11 wants to start a tradition of having a father/son dinner together at Tony's on all future trips. How can I say no to that?
Cinderella's Royal Table - B-/C .Obviously the main attraction is getting to meet Cindy herself. My DD8 loved the princess treatment, but the food was just okay. If DW & DD do CRT again, it would be for breakfast.
Le Cellier - A- . High expectations were well justified. If I could only go back to TWO restaurants from our last trip, this would be the second. Loved it.
Narcoossee's - B. Hmm...we really, really liked the atmosphere and the vibe at Narcoossee's, but the service and food were slightly disappointing. I would rate the service and food a "C", but the beautiful location and the adventure of going to this restaurant add to the experience. What was it about the food that disappointed me? The lobster was overcooked and tough. Otherwise, the crab cake appetizer and the almond-crusted cheesecake dessert were great. DW's lobster tail on the surf and turf tasted a little 'funny.' Please don't take this criticism as it being BAD. It's not....it's great! But the food fell a little short of our extremely high expectations.
Boma - B+. About as good as it gets as far as breakfast buffets go. I loved trying some of the exotic foods, like boboti. I would have liked to have seen a few more traditional items, though. (I'm from the south, so biscuits, gravy, and grits are always appreciated!) The jungle juice was out of this world!!! I could've drank an entire carafe by myself.
Pepper Market - C+. Not bad - not bad at all. If we had been on the regular dining plan, this would be considered a CS credit...and I probably would rank it higher. As it were, simply compared to all the other wonderful restaurants, it wasn't as great. DS had a fish taco that was really good, though.
Hollywood & Vine - F. Yep. An F. And I don't think I'm being too hard on this place at all....it was simply terrible. To me, the entire restaurant had a funky smell in it. The salads were wilted and soggy. The vegetables were right out of a large can, like you might buy at Sam's Club...think lunchroom cafeteria. The carving station did offer a decent beef prime rib, but that is just me trying to find something positive to say. The chicken nuggets tasted like TV dinners. I know everyone has differences of opinions, but I would not under any circumstances set foot in this place ever again! UGG!
Yak & Yeti - B+. Really, really good. The pan seared ahi tuna appetizer was wonderful, the shoaxing steak & shrimp was terrific, and the fried wonton dessert was TO DIE FOR!! DW wasn't as thrilled as me, so I decided to give it a B+ instead of an A. (She did like it very much, though - just not as much as me.)
Yachtsman Steakhouse - A-. Outstanding. The seafood salad was the best appetizer I had all week...perhaps ever. The chateaubriand was a real treat. I didn't have dessert, but DW, DS, and DD certainly enjoyed theirs. The shining star here was the wonderful service by servers Bill and Eric. Ask for them BY NAME! They will take care of you.
'Ohana (breakfast) - B. The characters were great! We liked the vibe at 'Ohana and I will try my best to get an ADR for dinner on our next trip. I think I would really enjoy dinner at 'Ohana. The breakfast food was good, but not great. The fruit was nice and fresh. The pineapple bread was INCREDIBLE!
Teppan Edo - C. This is your typical Benihana-type teppan grill style Japanese restaurant. Nothing too fancy - nothing out of the ordinary. I give it a "C" because we could have a similar meal back home anytime...therefore, it wasn't special. (It didn't help that we were seated next to a big mouth!)
Tutto Italia - B. I would classify this as a really good Italian Restaurant. Not a GREAT one, but a REALLY GOOD one. Is it better than Tony's? Yes, but it is also much more expensive. Again, we were on the Deluxe Dining Plan, and it is totally worth 1TS. However, if I were paying out of pocket, I think I would've been disappointed. $20 for spaghetti. The desserts were FAB! DW loved the profiterolles and the canoli. The service was not very good at all.
50s Prime Time Cafe - B+. I really enjoyed the interaction with our Aunt Sara! She ran a tight ship! In addition to the role-playing, the food was actually really good also. I had the meatloaf and it was great. The shakes, the onion rings, the ice cream dessert...all great! The only reason I didn't give it an "A" (besides the fact that I rarely give As) is because it is crowded and a little slow at times. But that's just me being overly picky. It's great, and it probably should get an A.
Kona - A. My expectations were not as high for this restaurant, but it ended up being one of my very favorite meals of the entire week! The prime rib is outstanding! The sticky wings as an appetizer could easily make a full meal. (SOOO good!) The kids loved their Kona Cones - it was their favorite dessert of the entire trip. I WILL be going back to Kona!
So....
Restaurants I would like to revisit in Spring '09:
FOR SURE:
- California Grill
- Le Cellier
- Kona
- Yak & Yeti
PROBABLY:
- Tony's Town Square
- 50s Prime Time Cafe
PERHAPS:
- Yachtsman Steakhouse
- Liberty Tree Tavern
I would gladly go back to any of them, really, except Hollywood & Vine. I just want to leave plenty of space to try NEW things next time! In my next edition, I'll share some of the places we are thinking about trying next trip.