I haven't seen anyone reply as you have in quotes. But anyway why do you think your opinion is more important than others. They asked, I gave my opinion and it is as valid as yours. They both are hectic, loud, poor service, cramped, below average food and over priced. IMO not worth it.
Well, I certainly did see people reply as I described in the course of my paraphrasing. In my opinion, when you say "they asked" you are partially incorrect. But I could be wrong. In my view they asked which one of the two you would pick if you were going to choose one. But, you could of course say I misinterpreted the heading myself, that it really was a question asking if either was worth going to. However, instead I saw it as "which one of the two."
In general, people on the boards do love to pipe in and throw negativisms at the establishments they dislike, and often with great zeal. Few would argue that the negative energy here can often overwhelm any attempt at positive Disney talk. DISBOARD posters often see themselves as the voice of Disney truth, and IMO not often enough in a positive way. Not that Disney can do no wrong, they sure can, but IMO not enough folks seem to focus on what's RIGHT with Disney.
As for these restaurants, just try to be objective for a moment... the truth is the majority of people like these places. For instance, they get 3 and 3.5 stars out of 5 on Yelp and both get 4 of 5 on Trip Adviser. Additionally, if you know about the nature of written reviews, you know that negative reviews are MORE LIKELY than positive reviews to end up posted online. People in marketing will tell you unhappy customers are heard from FAR more often than happy ones. So hard to argue against the assertion that the majority of people like these places.
Sigh. So, anyway,
you are free to tell the OP to ignore mine, and I am free to tell the OP to ignore yours. I am pretty sure most people have been ignoring mine for several paragraphs at least.
And the OP can feel free to ignore us both.
Sure, it's fact that atmosphere at both places is noisy when compared to other casual dining in and around Disney. So sure, I think it's fair to warn people these are probably not first choice date night restaurants.
But, atmosphere aside, I am sure there are dishes at both places the OP will like, and others the OP will not like. Based on the hundreds of reviews I have referenced, the odds, happily, are in the OP's favor. That's really going to be what it comes down to. So who knows, really.
