DD10 is at grade 5 and has been attending Sylvan for 3 months. I do not see any significant improvement, but DD seems to like it and I plan to continue, at least, for a few more months.
Here is our situation...basically we have tried different options
I noticed DD has a learning problem since K and have been discussing with her teachers in every grade level. She attends public school and we are in a good school district. I sent her to enrichment center for phonics while she was in K and 1st grade. I paid $60 per hour for her school teacher to tutor her when she was in 1st grade, but it was only for about 4 months and did not continue when her teacher left the school. I did not think the teacher had her mind in teaching.
I also sent her to eScore which uses computerized program to teach the kids, after a few months I don't think it was what she needed.
She has a very good 2nd grade teacher. With the teacher's help, she got into the IEP program in 3rd grade for both language art and Math. Her IEP teachers for IEP are good in 3rd and 4th grade, I also help. I think her 3rd grade Language Art teacher was too busy at the time. Her class in the IEP program consists of 3 to 5 students and she has always been the top of the class for Math in the IEP program which got me worry. She knows the multiplication table from the back of her head, but the other kids are still struggling with addition.
What I realize is that when kids are behind, their level can be very different, what they really need is individual tutoring. I decided to pull her of the IEP program for Math. I am glad I did, she is doing okay, probably will be a B student.
I was considering either private tutor or Sylvan during summer. Sylvan is charging around $50 per hour, but with 3 kids per teacher, it is like $50 per 20 minutes. However, the problem is that success of private tutoring depends heavily on the teacher at this age, I am not able to get a teacher I have confidence in. I do not need a homework helper, I need someone to be able to focus on the area she has problem on. I do not have a good experience with the private tutor she had when she was in 1st grade.
I also aware that Sylvan does not pay the teacher well, and I am concerned about the quality of the teachers. I know they are certified, but it really does not mean too much for me. However, I bought the idea that they evaluate the kids, teach them based on the grade level they are in. They also emphasize that they have the material, which in opinion. is very important for reinforcement. (I know I can buy the exercise books etc). I am also aware that we are not guaranteed to have the same teacher, but I am giving this method a try. I do believe it depends on how the center is run and each child is different. If I am able to find a good teacher, I may switch.
To add..
During summer, I also sent DD8 to be tested as I was told by the teacher that she is behind is her reading. I thought she is bright and was surpised by the evaluation even I agreed (will leave that for anther discussion). After looking at the result, the center director was suprised as she thought DD8 does not need to attend the program. Not sure whether she said this because she thought it would be too much to pay for both kids. But then, after the first test, we were called back to do the second test for DD8 on the same day because they did not see any deficiency from the test, therefore they decided to give her a higher level test. I do think DD8 is behind in her reading, but as I said we are in a good school district.