We liked the sushi at California Grill, and also at Wolfgang Puck Cafe. DS tried some at Kona Cafe that was good, but he just sampled one variety there.
Great! Thanks everyone I want to surprise bf by taking him to one while we are down there. I think it will be great since I am not the least bit in to sushi.
California Grill has excellent sushi made by Yoshi, one of the first and finest of women sushi chefs. Wolfgang Puck can be hit or miss. Kimonos has an attitude problem.
If you can sneak over to the Hyatt Regency Grand Cypress, you'll find an excellent sushi bar in the lobby, of all places.
Sunshine Seasons at the Land Pavilion has sushi too!
Its a great spot for lunch as its counter service (so you don't need and ADR). They also serve paninis and other hot dishes that you may enjoy since you don't like sushi.
That noted, if you can get into CG during wishes that is a no brainer!!!
Actually, my DF and I ate at Kona Cafe in September and we were able to order sushi from Kona Island while dining at the Cafe. It was a wonderful addition to our dinner.