Hi Neighbor!! We really are neighbors
OK so here's the update...WOW what a roller coaster! First of all..thanks to the OP who just saved me (a single mother of 2 boys) almost $700!!! More than half off the fares I've seen!!!

So..as I was booking I picked the cheapest flights I could find in the afternoon 3 days before we are actually returning. I went back to look at the flights to double check I had the right ones (very frustrating they don't put the flight details on the final payment page) and the payment went up $70! LUCKILY..I used the back page instead of previous and it took me to my original flights. Needless to say, I booked immediately!
Here's the kicker...

Our family friend is coming with us but purchasing her own ticket. I purchased our 3 tickets for...drumroll please...$670.40! I called her to tell her and book her ticket, and the return fare ALREADY went up $100 on the SAME flight!
I'm going to keep checking to see what we can work out to get her the same price! This is the cheapest airfare I've seen to MCO in YEARS!!! Thanks DIS and OP!!