Although I don't totally hate it, I'm not a fan. We just bought one a few months ago to replace our side by side. The side by side never had enough width in the freezer for me, and besides, I loved the looks of the French Door style, so that's what we bought. Well, now I find that there's not enough room for tall stuff. So I find pros and cons-side by side-small freezer; French door-short distance between shelves. With the side by side we went out and bought a small chest freezer for the garage to deal with the small freezer issue. So I wish we'd bought another side by side this time.