We had room 5020 on the Magic this past Halloween. I loved it!! The room was great, the view was great and the location was great!! The only problem we had was the bathroom floor had water coming up through it, so halfway through our cruise they wanted to fix it and offered to move us to a new room. They wanted to move us just down the hall to the same type of room(just a window) and my husband said "If we are going to go through the trouble of packing all of our stuff up and moving halfway through our cruise, you need to offer us something better". And they did, we were moved to a cat 4 on deck 8!!
But, putting all that aside, I will always try to get one of the secret porthole rooms from here on in! They are well worth it.
Dena