sleigh ride or fireworks cruise?

[grad_dis_nut]

DH and I will be celebrating our first anniversary in WDW in two weeks....it is where he proposed and will always have special meaning for us--as if we needed ANOTHER excuse to go back

Here's my question: I want to surprise him with a romantic evening out....I was thinking dinner and then either the "sleigh ride" (really a carriage ride) from Wilderness Lodge or the MK fireworks cruise from the Poly or GF. Looking for opinions from those who've done either or both...which would be better???? I guess I'm concerned about it being cold on the water, but it could be just as chilly in the woods, no?

Thanks in advance.

PS of course, with just two weeks to go, it could be a moot point as there may be no availability anyway....

 

[nativetxn]

I think the sleigh ride would be the most romantic

 

[Efastpitch]

why not both. You can never be to romantic.
.

 

[mickeysaver]

You will most likely find better availability on the sleigh ride. I have had our fireworks cruise booked since the day it became available months ago.

We really enjoyed the carriage ride we took last year at FW. It was very romantic. Maggie