Silly Question About a Gift

GOOFY4DONALD

DH finished his plate at 50's Prime Time. They wer
Joined
Aug 22, 2006
Messages
4,199
I recently received a thank you gift. It was from a woman who is a consultant for a home based business. She gave me a nice basket with a few of her products inside along with a nice card. I wasn't expecting anything and I just loved it. I received a few comments from coworkers that it was just a tacky gift. I was just curious... Am I the only who doesn't have a problem with this? I too have a direct sales business and a lot of customers that love my product. I was thinking that they would be nice gifts but now I'm not sure.
 
I don't think it's tacky to give a gift like that. But I do think it's tacky to judge gifts, after all we always say it's the thought that counts right?
 
I don't think it's tacky to give a gift like that. But I do think it's tacky to judge gifts, after all we always say it's the thought that counts right?
this is exactly what I thought. She was kind enough to think of me at all.
 

I think it was nice of her to think of you. Any gift is a "present".
 
I too have a direct sales business and a lot of customers that love my product. I was thinking that they would be nice gifts but now I'm not sure.

Well, I would just make sure that you're giving them to people who will appreciate the products.
 
Well, I would just make sure that you're giving them to people who will appreciate the products.
well I certainly appreciated her gift... Guess that's all that matters. And you're right I certainly would want to waste my items on someone that would just think they are tacky.
 
I'm bummed that your co workers would tell you that a gift someone got you is tacky. Seriously, what's their motivation behind that? Even if I DID think a gift given to someone else was tacky, I'd just smile and say, "How nice of her to give that to you!" because that's MANNERS.
 
I recently received a thank you gift. It was from a woman who is a consultant for a home based business. She gave me a nice basket with a few of her products inside along with a nice card. I wasn't expecting anything and I just loved it. I received a few comments from coworkers that it was just a tacky gift. I was just curious... Am I the only who doesn't have a problem with this? I too have a direct sales business and a lot of customers that love my product. I was thinking that they would be nice gifts but now I'm not sure.

I'm on the 'not tacky' side.
 
I'm bummed that your co workers would tell you that a gift someone got you is tacky. Seriously, what's their motivation behind that? Even if I DID think a gift given to someone else was tacky, I'd just smile and say, "How nice of her to give that to you!" because that's MANNERS.

My thoughts exactly! :thumbsup2
 
I am in the not tacky camp. Saying it was tacky IS tacky. If someone I know gave me a gift like that I would be thrilled.
 
I am in the not tacky camp. Saying it was tacky IS tacky. If someone I know gave me a gift like that I would be thrilled.

I agree. Not tacky at all. At my wedding I received an avon product as my wedding gift (& yes she was an avon lady.). I thought that was a bit tacky but didn't say anything.
 
I think it is a nice thing for her to do. I also think that your coworkers are jealous that you got a basket of goodies and so they said that it was tacky. I bet if they had been offered one they would not have turned it down.
 
I recently received a thank you gift. It was from a woman who is a consultant for a home based business. She gave me a nice basket with a few of her products inside along with a nice card. I wasn't expecting anything and I just loved it. I received a few comments from coworkers that it was just a tacky gift. I was just curious... Am I the only who doesn't have a problem with this? I too have a direct sales business and a lot of customers that love my product. I was thinking that they would be nice gifts but now I'm not sure.

Saying "Thank You" with a gift is sweet. I would be touched by it. It doesn't matter where it comes from. But now I'm getting a little worried. I recently attended a basket auction for a good cause and won several baskets. I don't need the baskets but I know that they fit a few friends. Is it wrong of me to give those baskets as gifts to people I know would enjoy them just because I didn't purchase the things myself?
 
I agree. Not tacky at all. At my wedding I received an avon product as my wedding gift (& yes she was an avon lady.). I thought that was a bit tacky but didn't say anything.

I don't even think that this is tacky. A friend of ours sells Silpada and is notorious for giving Silpada gifts! We ALL love it! It shows that she's passionate about her company!
 
And you're right I certainly would want to waste my items on someone that would just think they are tacky.

Right. I feel like I didn't explain myself well before, and I"m having a hard time wording it now. If the person had given the gifts to one of your coworkers, well obviously they don't use the product and therefore would think it's "tacky" because they probably feel the items didn't cost the woman anything. So if you were to give something to someone like that, they might think the same.

If you were to give me some Amway product I don't use, I might have a moment of thinking the same thing (before remembering that it actually had cost money or the opportunity cost of selling it to someone else)...but if you were a Creative Memories consultant and gave me some goodies, I probably wouldn't. It's all in the perception. :)


I actually was given a Mary Kay lotion set from a friend who was a MK consultant at the time, for my bridal shower. I didn't think it was tacky at all. I barely used it, because I rarely use lotions, but she wanted to change that. :) It would have worked, too, except I got pregnant immediately and my sense of smell changed, and I couldn't bear the scents. :( I was so bummed that I only threw them away last month. Um, I got married in '03. :eek:


Saying "Thank You" with a gift is sweet. I would be touched by it. It doesn't matter where it comes from. But now I'm getting a little worried. I recently attended a basket auction for a good cause and won several baskets. I don't need the baskets but I know that they fit a few friends. Is it wrong of me to give those baskets as gifts to people I know would enjoy them just because I didn't purchase the things myself?

You bought the baskets, and you know your friends enough to know who to give each one to. I think you'll be fine.
 
Thanks for all the replies. It was actually a Mary Kay product. I don't normally spend a lot on lotions so this was a real treat. My gifts are from a food company so hopefully they will either be enjoyed or regifted to someone that will like them. Either way I wouldn't care.
 


New Posts





Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom