Well yeah, EMH in January, February or September when attendance is low would probably be okay. But you don't even need EMH from a stict "trying to fit everything in" point of few during those months. The parks aren't that crowded then. You can easily fit everything in during the day. But when all of Disney's hotels are filled to the brim, as they have been recently and will be all summer long.....EMH has turned out to be an awful plan.
Even back in January when they first unveiled the EMH evenings there was a noticeable increase in crowds in the MK in the late afternoon as guests poured into the park. I can not even comprehend how bad it will be in the coming weeks.
I'm even amazed at the response on these boards. Generally you'll always find a couple of people who disagree with the consensus opinion. But not on EMH evenings....it's an across the board negative review. Well, other than the folks who have reported that EMH was great in January. But comparing the crowds in Janurary to those in July is like comparing apples and oranges.
At least people who are Disney savvy and read boards like this have a clue. But all those poor people who don't buy the hopping option thinking that they'll have plenty of time with all of those EMH hours, well it's going to impact their visits in a negative way. EMH evenings are clearly an example of "more being less".