WDWKOOK
NOW WITH LESS TAG!
- Joined
- Mar 10, 2009
- Messages
- 18,106
I hadn't gotten an alert for your thread in sooooo long. I finally was back on the DIS today and went to your thread where I found that I missed some fabulous posts

Hello! I am Gramma Nancy. Grampa Jim and I get to go on this adventure next year with Paul, Melissa, Allie and Marshall. We are SO excited to get to do this again. We live in Arizona and don't get to see the kids as much as we used to, but when we do it is always a good time. Paul is a planner. He got that from me.He has planned two trips for us to Disney World already and we know #3 will be awesome too. It is so nice to have the details taken care of before we even get there. Melissa takes the best pictures.
We are lucky to have her along for that and the patience she shows with any hassles that come up during traveling from one coast to another. We just loved Wilderness Lodge and Port Orleans on trips #1 and #2, but it will be special to get to go to Wilderness Lodge again. It reminds us of the Grand Californian where the kids got married.
We have resort reservations and set up a Disney Trip savings account. Can't wait for what comes next. Hoping for free dining. Gotta put in one more jumping icon because it is how I feel about this trip.![]()
Welcome back to another fine PTR and another fabulous WDW vacation with your wonderful family!
Allie celebrated her 6th birthday last weekend, and we ventured to Legoland.
While this was different than her fifth birthday in Disney World, she still had a great time and we decided to share the day in a mini trip report on the CA section of the DIS boards, which you can check out here.
Hop on over and check out us Disney veterans become newbs in a new park.
There hasn't been much other WDW planning going on, but we are looking forward to it and spending spare time talking about ADRs. We'll post some of those plans soon.
We have been busy preparing for little Marshall and keeping up with Allie's activities. She's moving up a level in her swim class and all three of her dance classes this month. This Saturday though we are headed to Disneyland so we'll post some about our day next week sometime.


I bet she can dance better than Belle

Hi everybody. It has been a little bit since we posted here, but we are still excitedly planning our WDW trip. The plans got a bit of a curve ball yesterday when Disney announced the annual pass price increases. We're not complaining about it (or debating why they did it) but it does look like the AP option doesn't make sense for our WDW trip anymore. For those who want to see the over analyzed details, this post is for you.
Paul generally has me cross eyed with all the numbers but that's why I keep him around
Our baseline for comparison is a package at WL with 8 day park hopper and waterpark tickets which prices out at $4415. We are hoping to get free dining with the package (so the plan cost is not included in that total), but we calculated out the anticipated dining cost so we could see if there was a better option out there.
Calculating the dining cost was a bit of an exercise, but using the values for average meals at each of the restaurants we are considering from an online calculator here I filled out my own spreadsheet with the anticipated full price of the meal, price with AP discount, and the price with Tables in Wonderland. Then I set up the spreadsheet so we could pick our choices from the larger list and have it calculate the total meal cost for each option.
Initially, it worked out that the total with Tables in Wonderland was $1389, compared to $1441 without discounts. Unfortunately, adding an extra $50 to this negates our savings, making the total $1439. Interestingly, we could do better with just the regular AP discounts, which would come in at $1413.
For our lodging, if we go room only we expect to be able to get a room only discount of as much as 30%. I added a field in the spreadsheet for this, and compare the total cost of the discounted room, the minimum out of pocket cost food option, and the cost to upgrade Disneyland annual passes to Premier passes to the package price.
Initially these values were within $30 of each other (which we could likely cover with AP merchandise discounts) but with the increase the AP Room Only option would now cost $5279, which is $863 more than the package price. We also priced out doing what we did last year, where we purchase the minimum package to get free dining, but use APs for our park tickets. This works out to $5527, but we would have three days of base tickets to use at some future date.
It sucks cause I wanted a golden ticket!
We also priced out one other room only option, in which we could take advantage of our leftover 2 day magic your way base tickets from last year. This works out to be the cheapest option, and even paying full price for our meals the total cost comes to $4306. It means we only get about $110 total out of our leftover passes from last year though, and we would have to deal with paying out of pocket for food. Depending on discount availability, it is still definitely an option though. We'll have to see when discounts are announced.
Some other interesting information from the spreadsheet was that most QS meals are very close in price, and the average cost only varied by a few dollars. Our total for QS dining was $413.85 Also we did include the cost of snacks we would get if we were on the dining plan, because we love our snacks. They totaled $106. We even accounted for the resort mugs, which would cost us $53.97 if we don't get the package. With the way we dine, we are a great fit for the dining plan since we use up all of our credits and visit a few high cost character meals. We plan on one additional TS meal out of pocket, but this can be our last morning breakfast at Whispering Canyon which will be less than $50, even without any discount. When we compare our meal cost to the cost of the dining plan, we do save a little money, but not a whole lot since the plan would cost $1302. For me, the big benefit of "free" dining is not having to feel the pain of each highly priced meal during the vacation. I'd rather have it taken care of ahead of time.
Though the price hike on AP's here are depressing they make the trip to Disneyworld look like all that much better a value.
Yes they do, now I can go back to my spreadsheets comparing cell phone plans...
LOVE the spreadsheets and running all the numbers. What a great resource for everyone! That's really the only way to compare/contrast your options. Are your folks going to do the same thing as you?
As far as cell phones, here's my comparo experience: You just can't beat Virgin Mobile. We started out many years ago with them with flip phones and have used their iPhones for years. Just got my 6+ from them this summer and we also have a 5 & 6 with them. Unlimited everything and only about $30/month each. The iPhone costs more, but you break even in about a year and then you're paying about half per month Vs. contract plans. They run on the Sprint network and always work really well from WDW

Oh my goodness!!! This is why I just say "OK" when my son tells me what I should do. I credit undamaged brain cells from his healthy living and his passion for Disney. This is the guy to go to Disney World with!
