birkner
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2006
- Messages
- 8,140
A few people have let me know they want to be in all the groups, others have given me a "maybe", and others have said, "one only, please." I've been noting that on my master list.
I figure once I work out the approximate numbers for each list, the "maybe's" can decide if they want to be in one, two, or all groups (or something in between "two" and "all") and let me know that. I'll adjust lists as needed.
I see three possibilities for this. Again, input please, on which option everyone thinks is best:
A) Late-comers (those signing up after Aug 1) will have their own FE list, and it will be only them. They can "duke out" the rules amongst themselves.
B) Late-comers will be on their own list, but others (early-comers?) may sign up for that list. It will be your responsibility to let me know you want to do that.
C) Late-comers will be added to the existing lists, as they sign up. This will be with the understanding that they must give gifts to everyone (or each cabin) on their list, but the people already on the list are not required to give to the late-comers. (This seems a bit punitive, but if the late-people list is really short, it gives them a chance of receiving more gifts.)
I really think we need a decision on this (at some point, not right this second), rather than a let-the-latecomers-decide-which-option-they-want approach. By mid-August, I don't really want to be fooling with this other than to add a name here or there.
Well, yeah, I know. I just prefer a democratic approach rather than the authoritarian dictatorship. (Anyone familiar with the "peasants" scene in "Monty Python and the Holy Grail?") Let the people decide, and all that.
Besides, after a couple of drinks, I'll knock something out and it'll be fined. Or utter rubbish.![]()
My two cents is that you name the groups and make them now. If people want to be in more than one group, you just add them to the existing group.
On last years WBTA, people who came in at the last minute were in the last group as you can see from the FE list from last year.
See post FE
What some people did who had extra gifts is just randomly give them out during the cruise.
Just my thoughts...
