Keep trying for Coral Reef....we had lunch adr's and I wanted to swap to dinner. It took 3 weeks and trying like 2-3 times a day but I finally got a ressie. So don't give up.
The Cape May Buffet is also a really good seafood (and alot of other stuff) buffet. Now, it's not the same presentation as Coral Reef, but still very good. It also offers something for everyone.
I grew up in New England - so nothing can top seafood for me. But I did enjoy Coral Reef. The enviroment was the best. We were seated right in front of the tank. The funny thing is my husband and I were busy looking at the menu and out son (I think 4 at the time) jumped out of his chair into my hands - well there was a guys feeding the fish and swimming in the tank. Totally scared our son.