Hmmm... We have stayed in VWL and OKW many times, and recently stayed at BCV for 2 days then BWV for 8 then finally SSR for 3 nts on our last trip (aug 2004)... and we certainly never felt like we were sliding into the slums on the last leg of our trip. What can ya say but one man's trash, another man's treasure (tho I do agree that a walk-through, or certainly drive-through, tells ya nothing. When we were house-hunting we drove through one neighborhood and I whispered to DH, "We are NOT buying into THIS development!" It just didn't seem like our kind of place. 12 years later and we have owned not one but 2 homes in this same neighborhood. Why? THe location, the people -- it's all great. After we outgrew our first home, we found a larger, newer one 3 doors down that would soon go up for sale and we seized it! I never judge wholly by first impression anymore!)
For you SSR owners -- a compliment to your home resort. We actually felt that service at SSR was ABOVE the service we received at the other 2 resorts. The staff was extra helpful to me at check-in, and anytime I needed help, and the community hall CMs treated my kids so great! One night my dd and I were headed back from community hall, and up zipped a CM on a golf cart. He literally saw us, grabbed a cart and offered us a lift to our villa! Now that's service (and my dd was of course thrilled with the ride!) Bus service at SSR was THE BEST.
As for the view, I'm no party animal, and have never even been to PI, but I found the view from our SSR villa to be among the best we have EVER had at WDW. It's not like you're looking right into the faces of drunken partying fools -- think PI from a very great distance! Close enough to walk -- but not so close as to see detail. Just imagine looking across a body of water at colorful DTD twinkling lights, add some fireworks at midnight -- it's lovely. Sitting in the hot tub at the pool facing those lights is so niccce! If that's a step down, well step me down NOW -- I wanna go back!
Now that said, I do whole-heartedly agree that every person has their preferences and should use their own heart when deciding upon their choice of DVC "home" -- not just go by the opinions of another. Many tastes, many choices! VWL is a fave of mine (tho I do love some part of ALL DVC resorts). My son loves BCV. ANother son loves OKW. DD wants SSR (the pool CMs treated her like a 4 yr old QUEEN). DH is like me, loves a bit of all (but does not like valet, so move SSR and OKW to the top of his list). Notice that none of us holds BWV as our first choice. So where do we own our pts? BWV. Funny, funny world. And why pray tell do we own at BWV? Cuz that's all DVC offered us when we bought and we were too ignorant to know resales existed. Had we known we would like SSR so well, we might have held off adding on to our original BWV contract and bought some SSR pts, but hindsight is always, well, you know.
So... If anybody has a contract for 205 pts at OKW or VWL to swap with us and can find a way to do it without ROFR and all that other mess, let us know... meanwhile, we'll just enjoy our pts as they are, but give the advice to others get your pts wherever YOU want to be... (unless, of course, you get a really great deal and can get twice as many pts and a bunch of banked ones, in which case, forget the other stuff I said and BUY! All the resorts are great anyway, so no worries, mate! Owning at a "lesser fave" hasn't hurt us yet!)