Sanibel Island

YorkieLady

Earning My Ears
Joined
Apr 3, 2006
Messages
2
I plan to visit Sanibel Island this summer and wondered which of the 7 resorts I should stay at. I have a 6 year old child. If you have stayed at more than one, please rank them for me. Thank you
 
I have no idea if this is related to DVC but I have stayed on Sanibel for many years with my sisters. Our fav resort is Casa Ybel--awesome place. We have rented condos there. Good luck.
 
I've stayed at 3 of them, but ranking them would depend on your preferences.
Sanibel Cottages has the nicest rooms.
Casy Ybel is the most kid-friendly w/ kid's activities, has the largest pool, and has an on-site restaurant.
Hurricane House had free golf (at least for exchangers, don't know it that holds true for renters).
I've also been to (but not stayed at) Tortuga Beach Club, and liked it also.
These are all small resorts compared to DVC resorts.

Hurricane House has 15 2-br units.
Sanibel Cottages has 28 2-br units.
Casa Ybel has 74 2-br units and 40 1-br units.
Tortuga Beach Club has 56 2-br units (I think).
 
Captiva Island is attached to Sanibel, and the South Seas Resort there is a very beautiful resort with a variety of accommodations. It was virtually demolished by Hurricane Charley in 2004, and has just reopened -- therefore everything is new.

The Plantation Beach Club and South Seas Club are Hilton timeshares within the South Seas Resort complex. I'm not sure quite what they did, but it's possible that Hilton bought certain buildings or options on a certain number of rooms. I'd probably call South Seas Resort and ask them what the difference is between those clubs and the regular resort.

South Seas is somewhat more upscale than anything on Sanibel.
 

You've asked about one of my very favorite islands. It's a great place for a family vacation. We traveled to Sanibel when our son just turned one, and went back every year for the next 7 years! We haven't been back since the hurricane hit - but I understand the island has recovered nicely.

Check out this website:
http://www.sanibel-captiva.org/
Check out the rentals from private owners. Much cheaper than going thru a resort. We have always stayed at the Sundial Resort and rented from owners. Sundial has several pools and activities for kids. The main pool has a great, direct view of the ocean. The beach is great for shelling. Plus, the island has wonderful bike paths. Rent bikes. It's a great way to see the island.

We prefer to stay on Sanibel and visit Captiva. We really like being able to bike to restaurants and stores. It's flat, so it's an easy ride for kids. You can rent bikes for the week (I recommend Finnimore's Bike Shop). Captiva has a nice dolphin watch cruise. We have even rented a boat for a 1/2 day out of Sanibel, and cruised up to Cabbage Key and had lunch (loads of fun!).

Feel free to PM me. We really enjoyed Sanibel and have been talking about going back soon.
 
JimMIA said:
The Plantation Beach Club and South Seas Club are Hilton timeshares within the South Seas Resort complex. I'm not sure quite what they did, but it's possible that Hilton bought certain buildings or options on a certain number of rooms. I'd probably call South Seas Resort and ask them what the difference is between those clubs and the regular resort.

Those resorts (as well as the four I mentioned previously) were developed by a company called Mariner Corp. They are now all HGVC affiliated resorts. HGVC is the management company, and maintenance fees include a fee for them to manage the resorts. (Thankfully, that included access to Hilton's insurance, which paid off big time after Hurricane Charley). All units are owned by individuals, not HGVC. Each individual owner had a choice of whether or not to join HGVC. If they did, they had the same status as someone who bought an HGVC developed property, and could use the HGVC system. They could trade thru HGVC or RCI. Also thru II if they have an individual membership in II. HGVC only has access to units traded thru HGVC. Owners who didn't join HGVC could only trade thru RCI or II if they had individual memberships in those trading companies.
 
I totally forgot about Tortuga Beach Club. We stayed there in June and it also is a great place. Casa Ybel still tops my list but I would go back to Tortuga in a flash.
 
Thank you everybody who sent info on Sanibel Island. I have never used a newsgroup for info and I am a newbie to all the lingo. Anyhow, I bought pts in the DVC in Feb. and I am going to the Saratoga in June, but thought I would try to go somewhere else with my other points this year. That is why I specifically wanted info for the DVC resorts in Sanibel. I could not get into the Vero Beach or Hilton Head Resort this summer. How far out in advance do you really have to plan this?. Of course, when I purchased that piece of info was not discussed. I assumed, rather incorrectly that I would be able to go whenever. What was I thinking??? I really bought the place because of the flexibility, but I did not know I would have to plan my vacation to specific date and place so far in advance. I was a little miffed by this. Oh well. Any help on when to expect to get into the DVC resorts would be appreciated from this newbie.
 
I was raised on Sanibel but now live in Canada. I own a home on Captiva just next to South Seas and love the area. I believe that the opening of South Seas has been delayed until summer or fall. I would recommend Casa Y Bel or Sundial resort. Both are kid friendly and nice resorts. I would recommend renting a condo at these locations rather than from the hotel. Rates are usually cheaper than the hotel. There are many condo rental available on the Internet. I have three kids and they love the island, you can fish on the pier, boat to outer islands, and bike for miles. Visit J.N. Ding Darling, rent a bike, and visit Blind Pass for the best shelling in the world.

Enjoy
 
jncvh Oh - I'm so jealous. You have a home on Captiva?!?! I hope that you fared well during the hurricane. I really love Sanibel/Captiva and appreciate it's natural beauty. It's one of the real treasures of Florida :sunny:
 
I have to say everyone raves over the Sanibel/Captiva area but we are NOT fans. We stayed at the Sundial which gets some mixed reviews. We heard everything from god to bad on trip advisor. Let me tell you it is BAD. Condos are OK although ours was a dump while our neighbor had a great one. They are all individually owned so it depends on each owner and how the unit is maintained. Pool is plain,plain,plain and smallish. Sanibel itself is just not interesting to our family. We like our beaches a little more manicured. Imagine going down to the beach and having to step over all the beach "debris" to find a spot to lay out. Shelling is great but how many shells can you look at? Kids need to wear reef shoes in order to keep there feet from getting cut. West coast beaches in general are gorgeous but not this place, murky water, seawed, stiucks, shells, etc. Really an overrated place, Sanibel. Lots of pine trees and brush with bike paths mixed in. Captiva is nicer in my eyes but I still wouldn't stay there again either. Pros of these two areas are good dining, good biking, and it is qiuet. Fort Meyers accross the bridge is a seedy beach town with little or no appeal. Kind of a poor man's Fort Lauderdale I guess without the nice beaches and cool Las Olas Blvd. As for exchanges through DVC, I would guess it is a little late to exchange for this summer. If you are open to taking anything on Sanibel then you might get lucky. Good luck with this and sorry if I gave a less than glowing review of the place. It is on our "do not return" list. Oh yeah, I think the toll to get on Sanibel is around $5 now. Let us know if an exchange works fore you.


johnny
 
Johnnyfairplay said:
I have to say everyone raves over the Sanibel/Captiva area but we are NOT fans. We stayed at the Sundial which gets some mixed reviews. We heard everything from god to bad on trip advisor. Let me tell you it is BAD. Condos are OK although ours was a dump while our neighbor had a great one. They are all individually owned so it depends on each owner and how the unit is maintained. Pool is plain,plain,plain and smallish. Sanibel itself is just not interesting to our family. We like our beaches a little more manicured. Imagine going down to the beach and having to step over all the beach "debris" to find a spot to lay out. Shelling is great but how many shells can you look at? Kids need to wear reef shoes in order to keep there feet from getting cut. West coast beaches in general are gorgeous but not this place, murky water, seawed, stiucks, shells, etc. Really an overrated place, Sanibel. Lots of pine trees and brush with bike paths mixed in. Captiva is nicer in my eyes but I still wouldn't stay there again either. Pros of these two areas are good dining, good biking, and it is qiuet. Fort Meyers accross the bridge is a seedy beach town with little or no appeal. Kind of a poor man's Fort Lauderdale I guess without the nice beaches and cool Las Olas Blvd. As for exchanges through DVC, I would guess it is a little late to exchange for this summer. If you are open to taking anything on Sanibel then you might get lucky. Good luck with this and sorry if I gave a less than glowing review of the place. It is on our "do not return" list. Oh yeah, I think the toll to get on Sanibel is around $5 now. Let us know if an exchange works fore you.


johnny

Oh well, one mans paradise is another's slum.

Got to watch out for those Sting Rays too!! :banana:
 
ttfn3 said:
jncvh Oh - I'm so jealous. You have a home on Captiva?!?! I hope that you fared well during the hurricane. I really love Sanibel/Captiva and appreciate it's natural beauty. It's one of the real treasures of Florida :sunny:

I agree :thumbsup2 :sunny:
 
Thank you, the house did fare very well during last years hurricane season. The only damage I had was the vegetation. The house is a three story with the stilts on the bottom so if the water rose 10 feet it would not affect the house just the garage. I am lucky though that the house is in a private community with our own pool and beach, but anywhere on Captiva is nice. A nice resort to check out is Tween Waters Inn, great location, great beach. I myself prefer Captiva over Sanibel as it is less busy and less touristy than Sanibel.
 
manning said:
Oh well, one mans paradise is another's slum.

Got to watch out for those Sting Rays too!! :banana:



Very true. We had heard so many great things about the place that we were shocked that we didn't like it. To the OP, try to get the exchange if you can. Check it out for yourself. Most people love it. Part of the problem for us is there realy isn't a good full service resort there. We picked Sundial and I already stated what I thought of that place.


johnny
 
Funny you guys should mention Sanibel. There was a National Geographic special on the other night about the crocodiles on Sanibel. It used to be a policy on the island to let the animals roam free, despite becoming larger and larger. There were a couple of attacks on humans, and a death, which forced the island to reform their policy on crocs. Now, when they get too large 4-5 feet, they're killed by hunters at night, with bows. Those were some nasty looking beasts.

We ran into some Brits at WDW during our last visit, who make a habit of visiting Captiva yearly. They were upset about damage from the storm. I've never made it there, but hope to sometime in the future.
 
In our opinion North Captiva is the place to go. We will be there in 6 days. Followed by a few nights at WDW. We go every couple of years and love. You can only get to the island by boat and there are no cars, just private homes. It will be interesting to see what the storm did to the island. My understanding is that on North Captiva a new channel was created by the hurricane separating the island into two.

HBC
 
Olaf said:
Funny you guys should mention Sanibel. There was a National Geographic special on the other night about the crocodiles on Sanibel. It used to be a policy on the island to let the animals roam free, despite becoming larger and larger. There were a couple of attacks on humans, and a death, which forced the island to reform their policy on crocs. Now, when they get too large 4-5 feet, they're killed by hunters at night, with bows. Those were some nasty looking beasts.
I'd be interested to see a link to that info. I searched National Geographic Channel for both crocodile attacks and Sanibel and got absolutely nothing. I'm a Florida native, work for the National Park Service, and have NEVER heard of a crocodile attack, much less a death, in the United States. Seems like that is something that would receive at least casual interest in the news media.

We do have American Crocodiles at the southern tip of Florida, usually from about Cape Sable in Everglades National Park to the Turkey Point Nuclear Power Plant east of Homestead, Florida. In fact, this is the only place in the world where alligators and crocodiles live in the same ecosystem. They are primarily around the tip of Florida, but they range up both coasts. There have been at least two crocs at the J.N. "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Reserve (administered by U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service) on Sanibel, and last summer two 12-footers were removed from a lake at the University of Miami campus in Coral Gables. The croc(s) at Ding Darling have been there for a number of years without incident, and the two at UM caused no problems either.

[ETA: American Crocodiles are also an endangered species, and hunting them would be an extremely serious felony under both U.S. and Florida Law. I can't even begin to think of the consequences to National Geographic if they filmed the hunting of an endangered species!]

The lower west coast of Florida, especially around Cape Coral, Ft. Myers, Sanibel, etc, DOES have a major problem with Nile Monitor Lizards -- an exotic species brought in for the pet trade. Monitors are very aggressive, grow to 7+ feet, and could clearly be a threat to humans. It's possible Monitors were the species in the NG story; they get big enough to be confused with a crocodile. We have a similar problem in Everglades NP with Burmese Pythons, also a downside of the pet trade.

However, American Crocodiles are quite docile -- nothing like their cousins in Africa or Australia, both of whom are extremely aggressive. We have something under 1,000 American Crocodiles in Everglades NP, and I have never heard of one even hissing at anyone, much less any aggressive action. They don't even protect their nests or young.

I'll check with our croc guy at Everglades if you really think the show was about crocs, but this sounds like either a misunderstanding or an urban legend to me.
 
Perhaps it was alligators, not crocodiles. I know that perhaps a year ago or so there was an unfortunate death due to an alligator attack. I think it was a landscape worker clearing brush/debris from around a home, and a very large alligator was accidentally disturbed, and attacked the person.
 














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top