RPR or Portofino?

[Amber74]

I know there are alot of threads like this but I thought I had my mind made up. I just got a 40% off for Portofino. I was going withRPR because it was the cheapest with AP discount. Now it would only be $100 total over 2 rooms and 4 nights. Don't know what to do! More room but further away and never stayed there before. Help?!

 

[damo]

There are 3 pools at the PBH. One has a great water slide. There is great pizza at Sal's...perfect for teens to just take off and go. The walk really isn't that much further if you take the shortcut....still under 10 minutes. I like the extra space but it really is a personal decision.

 

[macraven]

book the one that you think will be best for you and the family.

there are things to like/enjoy at each of the onsite hotels.

 

[Amber74]

book the one that you think will be best for you and the family.

there are things to like/enjoy at each of the onsite hotels.

That's the problem. Lol All 3 have something I like for my family. But I think with 3 adults, 2 big teens, and 2 younger ones the 450 sq ft might be better for us. It is such a good price for PBH that I don't think I can turn it down. I can stay at RPR next time. Shhh. Don't tell DH I said next time. Lol

 

[RMulieri]

There are 3 pools at the PBH. One has a great water slide. There is great pizza at Sal's...perfect for teens to just take off and go. The walk really isn't that much further if you take the shortcut....still under 10 minutes. I like the extra space but it really is a personal decision.

Agree..RPR is nice, but PBH was breathtaking and not THAT much further of a walk.It is a nice walk too.

 

[Amber74]

Talked to DH and he said it is a "no brainer". Talked to DS16 and he said "That's cool" with an excited look on his face. That doesn't happen very often so I have my mind made up. Our first time to PBH! Just booked and got 2 connecting garden view rooms for 4 nights over weekend for $1560! Never seen it that low before. Just paying $100 more than my RPR rooms. So excited to start pinning down all details!

 

[damo]

Talked to DH and he said it is a "no brainer". Talked to DS16 and he said "That's cool" with an excited look on his face. That doesn't happen very often so I have my mind made up. Our first time to PBH! Just booked and got 2 connecting garden view rooms for 4 nights over weekend for $1560! Never seen it that low before. Just paying $100 more than my RPR rooms. So excited to start pinning down all details!

The bigger bathrooms may be a big help with the double sinks.

 

[Amber74]

Didn't know about that one Damo. Thanks for everyone's replies.

 

[JessicaR]

I would grab Portofino Bay in a NY minute.

 

[mayesq]

I love both hotels, but with that many people I would definitely go with Portofino. It is a beautiful resort.