Reviews: Emeril's, Pat O'Briens, HRC, & Mythos

tarheelmjfan

Proud Redhead
Joined
May 10, 2001
Messages
13,736
I'll be dividing my review into 3 threads, & posting them on the pertinent boards. I will preface by saying that we are foodies, & dining is our number 1 priority on vacation. We don't regard food as merely sustenance. This means that we may be more critical than most. I wish I would have taken a few notes. The details provided are from memory, which can be a problem for me. :rolleyes1

Dining will be my DH, DS(14), & I. Our DS has been ordering off the adult menu, since he was 2. He's very much a foodie, as well.

Emeril's @ CW:
We had dinner here on our 3rd evening at UO. This is one restaurant that we almost always visit. We had an 8:30 reservation. Admittedly, I can't seem to be on time for anything, & tonight was no exception. We were about 5 minutes late, & had around a 15 min. wait. The place was packed & they were turning people away. We were seated next to the kitchen doors. After freezing @ Mama Della's & Tchoup Chop, I've never been so happy about a table assignment. :teeth: The service was attentive, as usual. The atmosphere was very nice. IMHO, nothing's worse than going to a fine dining establishment & needing ear plugs to make it through the meal. The kids we saw were all well behaved.

What we ate:
We began by ordering iced tea, while we looked over the wine list. We decided on a Robert Weil Riesling, which we enjoyed. A waiter comes by your table offering an assortment of bread. We all chose something different. I chose a muffin, which was great & IMO the best of the choices. We then moved on to appetizers. My DH & I shared the Smoked Wild & Exotic Mushrooms. This was fabulous. I could have been more than happy making a meal out of it. It was the best appetizer we had all week. My DH doesn't really like mushrooms, but I talked him into sharing anyway. He's a bit of a pushover. ;) I was surprised, when he raved about it too. Our DS ordered the Seafood & Andouille Gumbo. He said it was good, but he'd had better gumbo elsewhere. It's now time for our entrees. DS & I both ordered the Hickory Smoked Duck. We love Emeril's duck & order it every visit. It didn't disappoint! The flavors all blended perfectly together. The sides complimented but didn't overpower the duck, which is how it should be. My DH ordered the Double-Cut Pork Chop. This was his 1st time ordering this dish & he was a bit disappointed. It wasn't bad, but he's had much better dishes there. The sides were great, but the pork tasted very similar to Hormel. :p It's now "show time"!!! Yes, this means dessert is on the way. I placed an order for the Grand Marnier Souffle, when I ordered my entree. My DH ordered the Vanilla Bean Creme Brulee w/ Berry Sauce, & our DS ordered Bread Pudding. I should add that it's irrevelant which dessert my DH & I actually order, because we always share them. IMHO, this Souffle isn't quite as good as the Chocolate Souffle they removed in favor of this one, but it's still very good. I just had to try a bite of the bread pudding also, & it was as great as the other 2. Noone left a bit on their plate. :blush: In case anyone else likes to split desserts with their honey, the souffle & creme brulee really complimented each other perfectly. If you only order one to share, we thought the creme brulee was a little better than the souffle. With dessert, I had a glass of Chenin Blanc Ice wine, & my DH had a glass of port. The Ice wine was even better than Inniskillen. I would give the meal as a whole a B+.

Pat O'Brien's:
This was the day we rented a cabana. My DH stopped by Pat O's on our way out of IOA to get dinner to go. It was kind of early for us to eat dinner, so my DH & I shared a cheeseburger. Our DS is always starving, & got his own cheeseburger. We think Pat O's makes the best burgers on Universal property. These were just as good as usual. He also got a couple orders of Beignets. They were okay, but they aren't Cafe du Monde beignets. The burgers get a B. The beignets get a C-.

Hard Rock Cafe:
This was the lunch our DS was most looking forward to. Not because of the food, but he was excited that we had made arrangements to take the Backstage Tour. My DH & I both ordered a Bacon Cheeseburger. Our DS ordered Fajitas. Out of curiousity, we ordered the Sweet Potato Straws to share. Boy, were we glad we did. The burgers were as bad as Pat O's were good. We ordered them medium well & they closely resembled a charcoal briquet on a bun. They were inedible. Good thing for the sweet potato straws. They were good, & what we had for lunch. Our DS didn't eat much of his fajitas either. I don't know, if he didn't like the dish or if he was too excited about the Backstage Tour to eat. On a side note, he absolutely loved the tour. It was the highlight of his trip, & worth the horrible food. Tip: If you order a burger here, get it medium or even medium rare. This meal gets an F, but the tour redeemed it.

Mythos:
We made a 6:30 reservation, because we were going to US after dinner to watch Universal 360. We arrived about 15 minutes early & were told it would be a 15 min. wait. Another party was told the same. No problem. This usually means the place is packed, which is a good sign. After the short wait, we were escorted into the restaurant. Imagine our surprise when we get into the restaurant & see that only 1/2 of the tables are full. The lower level seating was full. We were the 1st table seated in the upper level & noone was dining outside.

What we ate:
We placed our drink orders fairly quickly. We were then given bread & butter, which was okay. I like the bread better than my DH did. For appetizers my DH & I shared the Mozarella & Tomato Flatbread. It was very good. Our DS ordered the Tortilla Soup. He enjoyed it, but wasn't blown away by it. For entrees, my DH & I then ordered the salmon. This is no longer served on a cedar plank & wasn't as good as we'd remembered. It was okay, but not great like it used to be. Our DS had a chicken dish that was good, but I don't remember many details. I wish I could tell you about the wonderful desserts we tried, but there would be no yummy, sweet creations for us this meal.

The service we had here was really bad. None of us were offered a drink refill. That wasn't the worst part though. As you can probably tell, we like having dessert with dinner. We were totally shocked, when our server cleared our entree plates, then returned with the check. She didn't even offer dessert. :confused3 We saw other servers on the lower level carrying around a dessert tray, but noone came near us with it. Our server laid the check down & said, "I'll take the check, as soon as you're ready." She didn't bother asking, if we needed anything else. She walked by to pick up the check, then returned to place it back on our table & didn't say a word. We're not ones to speak up, so we just let it go. Dessert that night ended up being fudge that we picked up at the candy shop in US on our way back to our hotel after watching Universal 360. All was well. :) We would give the overall experience a C- at best.

Summary:
We'll definitely be returning to Emeril's & Pat O's. We will no longer waste a dinner at Mythos. We will dine there again, but it will be for lunch. I'm glad our DS has taken the Backstage Tour @ HRC. We won't be going there again.

Sorry, this was so long. I hope it wasn't too boring. :blush:

Edited to move meals eaten at HRH to correct board.
 
We loved those beignets...first time we ever had 'em..... And sorry your Mythos experience wasn't "all that"....we had a great meal & service there....we'll definately be returning (fwiw, they must have been understaffed w/ servers if most of the place was empty...keeping people together in the same area for the servers' areas)....don't know why they'd be short staffed--they were voted #1 like 3 years in a row..... :confused3
 
We'll return to Mythos too. It just won't be for dinner. This has been a must do on our list, but wasn't as good as in the passed. The service did have a huge impact on the meal. Maybe they were understaffed, but the people on the lower level didn't seem to be having a problem getting refills & dessert. I need my dessert!!! :p I do have to admit that I wonder about the #1 ranking. We've always felt Epcot WS had a couple restaurants better than Mythos. Mythos has a great atmosphere though.

I agree that the beignets were good. We didn't have a problem eating most of them. :teeth: I just wanted to let anyone who had eaten beignets at Cafe du Monde in NOLA know that they weren't the same. I was hoping they would be, but that would be a lot to live up to. The beignets at Cafe du Monde melt in your mouth. Okay, we need to book a trip to NOLA now. ::yes:: We do love Pat O's @ CW though.
 
tarheelmjfan said:
I do have to admit that I wonder about the #1 ranking. We've always felt Epcot WS had a couple restaurants better than Mythos. Mythos has a great atmosphere though.

I think it's the quality of the food and the pricing. Some of the menu items are pretty inventive (I've had to ask them to repeat the Risotto of the Day more than once... lol.. And I still didn't really understand it) but it's not too expensive at all. Plus the atmosphere and the amazing view of the park...

In that sense, Mythos has very little competition.
 

nerdboyrockstar said:
I think it's the quality of the food and the pricing. Some of the menu items are pretty inventive (I've had to ask them to repeat the Risotto of the Day more than once... lol.. And I still didn't really understand it) but it's not too expensive at all. Plus the atmosphere and the amazing view of the park...

In that sense, Mythos has very little competition.

You're probably right about the reasons. IMHO, the food at Les Chefs de France is much better than Mythos. We also think Le Cellier is better, although we're not LC groupies like many on here are. ;) There's a few more WS restaurants that I would say are equal to or maybe a little better. However, they all cost us a lot more to eat there. If you're judging on value, Mythos would win. If you're judging on food quality, it would be a different story. Personally, I think Mytho's menu is more appropriate for lunch. Since they're not open for dinner a large portion of the year, they probably don't feel a need for a seperate menu. I think the menu is too limited for dinner. We never minded, because we loved the salmon. As I mentioned earlier, the salmon just wasn't as good as it used to be. Why fix something that isn't broken?
 
Thanks so much for posting, I really enjoyed your reviews :thumbsup2 I'm glad your DS liked the HRC tour. We will be dining there next week. My DD loves the Beatles and is very excited about taking the tour. I think this will be her highlight as well. I'm sorry to hear the food wasn't very good. I think the look on DD's face when she takes the tour will more than make up for the food.
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top