Mrs. Ciz
DIS Veteran
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2011
- Messages
- 3,817
There simply isn't enough 'free' aid to go around. Period. Yes, some of these huge schools have fat endowments...with big restrictions on how they can dole that money out. Big U also has fat athletic programs...they get (and give) boatloads of cash to talented athletes who by their talent raise (or keep) the school in the limelight.
Most students or parents with any expectation that they will get enough 'free' aid to go to the school of their choice/dreams/desires just because they worked hard and got great grades is going to be disappointed. The great shot for free rides (ala National Merit scholarships) have their fates sealed through their PSAT and/or SAT scores taken in their junior year of HS.
I have known some very smart hard working students. One in particular was studying engineering at Rutgers University and doing very well. Some aid, but mostly of the student loan variety (which again, IS classified as aid).
You're both correct. I wasn't trying to imply that the frugal family would not come out ahead in the long run.
I was responding to another poster's comment that the government doesn't want to subsidize families who have spent foolishly rather than saving. Since EFC is partly based on how much you have saved (parents are expected to contribute 5.64% of their savings-- and students an even higher percentage), the non-savers are in fact being subsidized because their children will qualify for more financial aid (since they will have a lower EFC than the savers).
My DH had a really hard time understanding this! He was angry that our 529 Prepaid College Savings Plan made our EFC higher. He kept saying we got screwed because we saved; now our kid won't get any aid. What he failed to realize is that most aid is NOT free; it is of the loan variety. In the end we are much better off and will pay less overall because we DID save. We won't have to take out loans to meet our EFC. We won't have to pay back $$$$ in interest. It is sometimes hard for folks to understand all the ins and outs, especially when it's their first kid and first college funding experience.
Last edited: