I totally agree! This october will be our 3rd time renting points. I never try and barter with the owner. The family always wants to stay at either the BCV or the BWV. I'm happy just to get in there at the reduced rate of renting points so I never question.
I've dealt with some great owners( one in particular) and have never had a problem. (knock on wood....
) I'd rather go with someone with a higher post count also. I wouldn't feel comfortable renting from someone with a single post count.
You are being very wise. I rented before I bought, I paid top dollar, she was great to deal with.