I will say that if you do need full and valuable advice then I would suggest posint on the relevant DVC board.
That said as a fellow Disney Bride and Honeymooner let me talk you through my thoughts on this subjet:
I own DVC but LOL not nearly enough points for how much I travel but the hubby doesn't believe in loans so unless I have all the cash up front to make a full payment I'm not allowed to buy anymore points so I end up renting extras
I usually rent at $10 a point but that's just from my buddies. I have friends who have rented using the DVC rental board and they rented at $11-$12 and from my experience that does seem to be the going rate. It can still work out a lot cheaper than paying out to stay in a Deluxe. Obviously there is a big downside for me in staying at a DVC property on points, someone doesn't come make my bed everyday - if I'm on my honeymoon I want this to happen LOL
Romantic choices hmmm well I've stayed in all the DVC resorts except Saratoga but I spent nearly a whole day there in December in my girlfriends one-bedroom. I would deffo recommend the one-bedroom if you can because the King Bed and Jacuzzi bath in the Master Bedroom make that romantic stay even more romantic
Beach Club Villas - I love the location and the amenities and being able to do Stormalong Bay is fabarooney, we stayed here for the tail end of our honeymoon and loved it, it's our home resort, but we had just spent a romantic week on the Disney Magic - so I couldn't necessarily say that I found BCV a romantic ambience.
OKW - The villas are all big here and I find this resort a lot quieter than the Boardwalk or BC. But I do find the rooms here very "tired" looking and not as shiny. It doesn't spell romantic for me as such but definitely soothing and relaxing.
Boardwalk - This can be romantic - the rooms are big and just being on the Boardwalk and eating at a different place every night then just walking back to your room is just great. Sitting on that Boardwalk and people watching ::sigh:: yup it can be a romantic place if a little "busy"
Saratoga Springs - if you're going to be room hermits then this would be my choice, they're so new and so tastefully decorated - I love this place and can't wait to stay here and it has that beautiful spa on site too. Can't really judge on romantic level just yet.
Wilderness Lodge Villas - We stayed here for our 1st Anniversary and I felt it very romantic - we had a woods view room and the ambience of this place is so rustic and Lodge like, with winding paths and the beach so close, and the lagoon - that fireplace in the Lodge itself - I love the pool. Yup this would be my pick of romantic DVC resorts.
Hope that helps
