I'll bet the answers tend to vary depending on what part of the country people are from. For example, when we lived in Massachusetts, we used to cut our tree at a local Christmas Tree farm (appropriately called Love's!). Like Sparky in "Christmas Vacation", I felt it was all part of the experience. Wouldn't consider an artificial tree. Now that we're here in South Texas, the real trees are trucked in by Thanksgiving, displayed in 80 degree temperatures, expensive, and vry dry. Here, I couldn't imagine anything but an artificial tree. The real trees are so sad compared to what we had. But I do miss that smell!